Baseball’s never been short on smack talk. Some MLB stars have turned chirping into an art form—flipping bats, jawing at pitchers, and strutting around the diamond like they owned the place.
But the moment someone dared to toss a little heat back in their direction? Total meltdown. These are the guys who could dish it with the best of them—but absolutely could not take it.
18. Yasiel Puig
Puig loved a good bat flip and wasn’t afraid to get animated after big hits. But he was quick to take offense when pitchers dared to celebrate their own success.
17. Bryce Harper
He plays with flair and never met a camera he didn’t like. But let an opponent throw a little shade, and he suddenly goes full drama mode.
16. Josh Donaldson
The “Bringer of Rain” never shied away from chirping at the dugout or posing after a homer. But if you even blinked at him wrong, he took it personally.
15. Carlos Gómez
Gómez was known for some electric (and loud) celebrations on the base paths. But pitchers firing back with attitude didn’t sit well with him at all.
14. Manny Machado
Machado is the king of cool when he’s winning and loves a little on-field swagger. When things aren’t going his way, though, he tends to get testy—fast.
13. A.J. Pierzynski
Pierzynski talked nonstop and was constantly in the middle of something. But when the tables turned, he was usually the first to lose his cool.
12. Trevor Bauer
He had no problem stirring the pot, trolling opponents, and making videos about it. But anytime he was on the receiving end, things got extra sensitive.
11. Jose Bautista
Bat flip legend, no doubt. But when pitchers responded with a little heat or a hard slide, Bautista did not take it well (just ask Rougned Odor).
10. Nyjer Morgan
“Tony Plush” had a whole alter ego built on trash talk and flair. But even the slightest clapback had him seeing red.
9. Jonathan Papelbon
Papelbon was the ultimate fist-pumping, stare-down-throwing closer. But if anyone celebrated a win against him, he treated it like a personal attack.
8. Alex Rodriguez
A-Rod never lacked confidence and knew how to needle an opponent. But when the crowd turned or pitchers challenged him, he could be visibly rattled.
7. David Wells
He was loud, proud, and loved making headlines. But he wasn’t exactly great at handling boos or getting shown up by hitters.
6. Brian McCann
McCann fancied himself the unwritten rules police, often lecturing others about decorum. But he was far less vocal when teammates did the exact same stuff.
5. Carlos Zambrano
Zambrano loved barking at hitters and showing emotion on the mound. When things went sideways, though, his tantrums were legendary.
4. Barry Bonds
Bonds had a stare and strut that oozed intimidation. But when pitchers threw inside or didn’t pitch to him, he made it known he wasn’t pleased.
Read More: 10 MLB Players Who Thought Every Pitcher Feared Them
3. Roger Clemens
Clemens threw at guys regularly and glared like it was a sport. But if anyone dared to celebrate a homer off him, he took it like a personal insult.
Read More: 15 MLB Players Who Threw Shade But Couldn’t Catch It
2. Curt Schilling
Schilling always had something to say and never passed up a chance to stir the pot. Criticism, however? That was met with endless deflection and outrage.
Read More: 15 MLB Players Who Made Every At-Bat About Themselves
1. Madison Bumgarner
Few pitchers dished it out like MadBum, especially with his stares and growls. But if anyone flipped a bat or celebrated, he acted like baseball’s moral compass had shattered.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
