The NFL has changed a lot since the 1990s—offenses are faster, rules favor quarterbacks, and mobility is more important than ever. But some ’90s signal-callers were so ahead of their time, they’d fit right into today’s game and maybe even dominate.
Whether it was arm strength, football IQ, sneaky athleticism, or just that unshakable confidence, these guys had the tools to thrive in any era. Here are 10 quarterbacks from the ’90s who could easily start (and shine) in the modern NFL.
10. Drew Bledsoe
Before Tom Brady took over, Bledsoe was the prototype—big arm, tall frame, pure pocket passer. In today’s league with clean pockets and vertical passing attacks, he’d still be slinging it 40 times a game.
9. Randall Cunningham
Cunningham was doing the dual-threat thing before it was trendy. He had a rocket arm, electric legs, and the kind of improvisational skill coaches dream about now.
8. Brad Johnson
Johnson wasn’t flashy, but he was smart, efficient, and rarely made mistakes—basically the modern NFL’s favorite qualities. With today’s short passing schemes, he’d be a perfect game manager-plus.
7. Jeff Garcia
Garcia was undersized and mobile before that was cool, and he thrived in a West Coast system that would look right at home today. His grit and creativity would make him a fan favorite in the modern league.
6. Mark Brunell
Brunell was left-handed, elusive, and a great play-action passer—sounds a lot like what offenses want now. He was basically a slightly less flashy version of today’s mobile QB mold.
5. Troy Aikman
Give Aikman today’s protection and RPO-heavy schemes, and he’d still be carving up defenses. He had elite accuracy and decision-making, even without the fantasy-friendly stats.
4. Daunte Culpepper
Culpepper had size, speed, and a cannon for an arm—basically the blueprint for today’s dual-threat QBs. With modern spacing and QB-friendly rules, he’d be a nightmare to defend.
3. Steve McNair
McNair was built like a linebacker and played with a mix of toughness and mobility that would be elite today. He’d thrive in a spread offense, and defensive coordinators would still hate preparing for him.
2. Steve Young
Young had elite accuracy, mobility, and smarts—he was basically a left-handed, pre-social-media version of what teams crave now. Drop him into today’s NFL and he’d still be in MVP conversations.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Fitting Nicknames in MLB History
1. Brett Favre
Gunslinger mentality? Check. Ridiculous arm strength? Double check. Favre was chaos personified, and in a league that now celebrates creativity and off-script brilliance, he’d fit in like he never left.
Read More: 10 NFL Players Who Retired and Came Back
