The steroid era in Major League Baseball was chaos. Home runs were flying, neck sizes were doubling, and pitchers were either throwing 99 or giving up tape-measure shots every other inning.
But not everyone was juicing their way to MVP awards or SportsCenter highlights. Some guys were just out there doing their best to hang on, collect a few hits, and avoid being crushed by the avalanche of chemically enhanced talent around them.
23. Mark Loretta
Steady, solid, and the complete opposite of flashy. Loretta was the kind of guy who hit .300 quietly while all the noise was coming from the chemically blessed.
22. Kenny Lofton
Speed and defense were his calling cards in an era where bombs ruled everything. Lofton didn’t need a syringe to steal 60 bags and cover half the outfield.
21. Luis Castillo
Slapping singles and turning double plays, Castillo wasn’t about to start bench pressing small vehicles. He did the little things right while the big boys chased home run records.
20. Jason Kendall
He looked like a guy who got invited to spring training by accident but then stuck around for 15 years. Kendall ran hard, caught everything, and somehow avoided being totally overshadowed.
19. Steve Finley
Finley aged like a fine wine, and while suspicions floated, he never really fit the “bulked-up masher” mold. He just kept doing his thing while monsters roamed the diamond.
18. Craig Counsell
Counsell had a batting stance that made you uncomfortable, but it worked. He was the poster child for surviving the era with weird mechanics and no muscle mass.
17. Placido Polanco
Polanco made a career out of being unspectacular in the most dependable way. In a time of biceps and moonshots, he gave you line drives and gold gloves.
16. Tony Womack
Speed was his weapon, and he used it well. While others chased power numbers, Womack just tried to reach base and make things happen with his legs.
15. Mike Bordick
Bordick was a perfectly average shortstop at a time when shortstops were turning into power hitters. He stayed in his lane and carved out a nice career just being reliable.
14. John Olerud
Olerud rocked a helmet in the field and a swing built for contact. He wasn’t about to chase the long ball if it meant messing up his silky smooth approach.
13. Rey Ordoñez
If defense were the only thing that mattered, Rey would’ve been a star. But his light bat made him look even more old school in a time of juiced-up shortstops launching bombs.
12. Brett Butler
Butler was on the tail end of his career when the steroid wave hit, and he looked like a dad coaching Little League next to some of the monsters out there. Still, he ran hard, bunted well, and stayed relevant.
11. Rich Aurilia
He had one outlier power year, but otherwise, Aurilia just tried to hold down the fort at short. He played in Barry Bonds’ shadow and probably had whiplash from watching all those home runs fly out.
10. Eric Young Sr.
He played with hustle, not muscle. EY Sr. swiped bags and played multiple positions while others were busy adding inches to their biceps.
9. David Eckstein
He looked like your local DMV employee, but played like a guy with something to prove. While the rest of the league bulked up, Eckstein relied on grit and a strike zone the size of a lunchbox.
8. Tom Goodwin
If there was a club for “guys who got on base and hoped someone else drove them in,” Goodwin was president. He used speed and defense to avoid being left behind in the power boom.
7. David Bell
Bell had solid baseball bloodlines and a solid, unspectacular career. He didn’t cheat, didn’t mash, just tried to keep a job and not get flattened by the HR surge.
6. Scott Hatteberg
If you watched Moneyball, you know Hatteberg was more about OBP than OPS+. He didn’t hit bombs, but he found a way to stay employed in a league obsessed with power.
5. Chris Singleton
Singleton played center field with grace and hit just enough to stick around. He wasn’t juicing—he was just hoping to not get DFA’d.
4. Pokey Reese
Pokey was all glove and not much bat, but he found a way. You knew he wasn’t part of the problem, which made you root for him even more.
3. Mike Matheny
A defense-first catcher with a bat that was often an afterthought. Matheny caught some of the biggest stars of the era while clearly not partaking himself.
Read More: 20 MLB Stars Who Always Found a Way to Win
2. Doug Mientkiewicz
Gold Glove defense, light bat, and a name that announcers struggled with. Doug wasn’t out there trying to break records—he just wanted to play clean and field grounders.
Read More: Ranking the 20 Most Boring MLB Stars of All Time
1. Frank Catalanotto
The ultimate “just happy to be here” energy. Catalanotto got on base, played multiple positions, and somehow made a long career out of surviving the most juiced-up time in MLB history.
Read More: 25 MLB Players Who Were Quiet Legends in the Clubhouse
