Confidence is part of the job when you play in the NFL, but some guys cranked the dial past 10 and never looked back. Whether they were flexing after a three-yard run or predicting Super Bowl wins, these players built careers on swaggers.
From loudmouth quarterbacks to dancing receivers and defenders who celebrated every incompletion like a pick-six, these guys never doubted themselves, even for a second. They walked into every stadium like they owned it, and depending on the day, they might’ve been right—but their mouths always showed up whether their game did or not.
24. Chase Claypool
Claypool once claimed he was a top-three receiver in the NFL, which is a bold move for someone who couldn’t stay in the top three on his team. The confidence was admirable, but the production didn’t follow.
23. Jimmy Garoppolo
He had Tom Brady’s smile and a Hollywood jawline, and he carried himself like the heir to the throne. Unfortunately, injuries and inconsistency told a different story.
22. DeAngelo Hall
Hall talked a big game on and off the field, always ready with a quote about his dominance. He could make plays, sure, but he also gave up a few too many while hyping himself up.
21. Cam Newton
Cam’s confidence was electric and magnetic, especially during his MVP year. But even when things fell off, he still carried himself like the league was his runway.
20. Terrelle Pryor
Pryor believed he could be a star in multiple positions and let everyone know. That kind of confidence is admirable—until it turns into delusion.
19. Antonio Brown
AB was once the best receiver in football, and he knew it. He kept reminding us long after the league had moved on.
18. Richard Sherman
Sherman’s infamous “I’m the best corner in the game” moment was pure overconfident energy. He backed it up for a while, but the mouth never quieted—even when his play started to.
17. Vince Young
He came into the league fresh off a legendary college run and didn’t think he needed to prove a thing. That confidence carried him for a bit, but only for a bit.
16. Odell Beckham Jr.
OBJ acted like the NFL was his highlight reel—sometimes, it was. But the dancing, antics, and headlines often outweighed the actual stats.
15. Jameis Winston
He’s always believed in himself, maybe more than anyone else believed in him. His unwavering optimism is part charm, part chaos.
14. Jay Cutler
Cutler had the body language of someone who didn’t care what anyone thought, paired with the arm talent of a guy who thought he could make any throw. Sometimes he could. Usually, he couldn’t.
13. Chad Johnson
Ochocinco didn’t just think he was the best receiver—he thought he was the most entertaining human alive. And honestly, he might’ve been, but he wasn’t always the most productive.
12. Sam Darnold
Darnold carried himself like the guy, even when everyone else had moved on. That quiet confidence never matched the turnover count.
11. Michael Irvin
The Playmaker lived up to his nickname, but never missed a moment to remind you how great he was. Subtlety was not in his vocabulary.
10. Eli Apple
Apple never met a moment when it couldn’t talk trash, even when the scoreboard said otherwise. His confidence never took a day off, even if his coverage did.
9. Tim Tebow
Tebow believed in himself with a level of conviction usually reserved for cult leaders. You almost admired it—until he tried to make a baseball comeback.
8. Baker Mayfield
Baker entered the league already acting like a 10-year vet with a Super Bowl ring. The chip on his shoulder was real, but sometimes he played like it was the size of Texas.
7. Dez Bryant
Dez played with fire and swagger, always letting you know when he made a catch. The problem was when he didn’t make one and still let you know.
6. Philip Rivers
Rivers didn’t cuss, but he could trash-talk with the best of them. His endless confidence—and sidearm slings—were both unpredictable and relentless.
5. Johnny Manziel
Johnny Football thought the league would bend to his brand. Instead, it chewed him up while he tweeted through it.
4. Eli Manning
Eli’s face said “confused,” but his arm said “trust me, I got this.” He threw picks like he didn’t care—because deep down, he thought he was clutch every time.
3. Dion Lewis
He once said Tom Brady wasn’t that great after leaving the Patriots, which tells you everything you need to know. Confidence is key, but context is crucial.
Read More: The 20 Most Overconfident Tennis Stars of All Time
2. Joe Namath
Broadway Joe guaranteed a Super Bowl win and pulled it off, so props there. But make no mistake—his entire career was swagger-first, stats-second.
Read More: The 20 Most Overconfident MLB Stars of All Time
1. Deion Sanders
Nobody in NFL history has ever loved themselves more than Prime Time. He was flashy, loud, and backed it up, but the confidence was truly in a league of its own.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Overconfident QBs to Ever Play the Game
