Some NFL stars are first-round picks who were destined for greatness the moment they shook the commissioner’s hand. Others? They didn’t even get a phone call on draft day—just a shot, a chip on their shoulder, and a whole lot to prove.
These 15 players weren’t picked in the NFL Draft, but they still won over fans across the league with their heart, hustle, and highlight reels. From underdog beginnings to unforgettable careers, these guys turned rejection into a reason to root for them.
15. Wes Welker
He was told he was too small, too slow, and too forgettable. Then he became one of the most dependable receivers of his era and Tom Brady’s go-to guy for years.
14. Warren Moon
Despite winning a Rose Bowl, no NFL team drafted him, so he went to Canada and dominated. By the time he got to the NFL, fans already knew they were watching greatness in action.
13. Priest Holmes
Kansas City fans still talk about the way he ran through defenses like they owed him money. Undrafted and overlooked, he became one of the most productive running backs of the early 2000s.
12. Arian Foster
Once a backup nobody paid attention to, Foster exploded onto the scene with vision, patience, and one of the smoothest running styles in the league. Texans fans adored him—and so did fantasy football managers everywhere.
11. Chris Harris Jr.
He wasn’t a household name when he signed with Denver, but he didn’t need much time to become one. An undrafted corner who shut down top receivers and earned multiple Pro Bowl nods, Harris was a fan favorite with swagger.
10. Rod Smith
Before the Broncos had flashy receivers, they had Rod Smith doing the dirty work—and making it look easy. He came from nowhere and became one of the franchise’s all-time greats.
9. James Harrison
You wouldn’t want to run into him on the field—or probably anywhere, really. Harrison’s story was pure grit, and Pittsburgh fans loved every sack and scowl.
8. Antonio Gates
He never even played college football, which makes his rise even more ridiculous. The Chargers found a gem in Gates, who turned into one of the best tight ends the game’s ever seen.
7. Adam Thielen
A hometown kid from Minnesota who made good—fans ate that story up. He worked his way from practice-squad hopeful to Pro Bowl receiver with sure hands and even better route running.
6. Malcolm Butler
One play turned him into a legend, but he backed it up with years of solid play. Patriots fans will always remember that interception—and how he went from undrafted to unforgettable.
5. Kurt Warner
He was literally bagging groceries before becoming a Super Bowl MVP. Warner’s journey from undrafted to Hall of Fame was the stuff of football fairytales.
4. Jason Peters
Originally a tight end, Peters bulked up and became a wall at left tackle. He earned love in Buffalo and legend status in Philly—fans never forgot where he came from.
Read More: 25 Former NFL Stars Who Were Just Built for 2025 Football
3. Cameron Wake
He had to take the long route through the CFL, but once he got to Miami, he made every snap count. Dolphins fans adored his relentless motor and edge-rushing dominance.
Read More: 10 Undrafted NFL Players Who Became Super Bowl Champions
2. John Randle
With eye-black that looked like war paint, Randle played with unmatched energy and intensity. Undrafted but undeniable, he gave Vikings fans a show every single week.
Read More: 14 NFL Players Who Went Undrafted—and Got Paid
1. Tony Romo
He may not have delivered a Super Bowl to Dallas, but he gave fans plenty to cheer about on Sundays. Romo went from undrafted afterthought to face of the franchise—and now, one of the best voices in the booth.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
