Talking smack is practically part of the job in the NFL. But for every legend who matched their mouth with highlight-reel plays, there’s a long list of players who talked a big game and delivered not much else.
This list goes out to the guys who ran their mouths like All-Pros but played like benchwarmers. Whether it was preseason confidence, midgame jawing, or postgame delusion, these 20 players proved that sometimes silence is golden.
20. Dre Kirkpatrick
He had all the confidence in the world but rarely made plays to justify it. Quarterbacks didn’t exactly fear throwing his way.
19. Anthony Smith
He guaranteed a win over the undefeated Patriots and got cooked all day long. That one quote pretty much defined his whole career.
18. Adam “Pacman” Jones
Pacman never shied away from the mic, but penalties and off-field drama often spoke louder than his game. He talked tough, but the results were rarely elite.
17. Freddie Mitchell
He called himself “FredEx” because he always delivered except when he didn’t. One good playoff game couldn’t carry all that bravado.
16. Vontae Davis
He hyped himself up like a shutdown corner, then literally quit midgame. That’s not exactly the ultimate way to back up your words.
15. Mike Mitchell
He jawed with everyone like he was an All-Decade safety. Problem is, his play was more noise than substance.
14. Jalen Reagor
He clapped back at fans and critics early in his career. Then proceeded to drop passes and get traded.
13. Johnny Manziel
He came into the league with swagger and a money sign. But his trash talk aged about as well as his NFL career.
12. Cortland Finnegan
He was constantly chirping, even instigating fights. But he rarely backed it up with actual dominant coverage.
11. Josh Norman (late career)
Early on, he walked the walk, but later he just kept talking. Opposing receivers stopped being scared and started padding their stats.
10. Le’Veon Bell (post-Steelers)
He talked like he was still elite long after his production fell off a cliff. Bold strategy for a running back on the decline.
9. Matt Hasselbeck
“We want the ball and we’re gonna score” might be the most infamous trash-talk line ever. Then he immediately threw a pick-six.
8. DeAngelo Hall
He never hesitated to pop off, but he gave up just as many big plays as he made. Talking smack while getting toasted isn’t a great look.
7. Kellen Winslow II
He once called himself a “soldier” in a bizarre rant. But his career was filled with injuries, inconsistency, and unmet expectations.
6. Baker Mayfield
No shortage of quotes, gestures, or media soundbites. But his play never quite lived up to the energy he put out.
5. Richie Incognito
He talked like he was a dominant enforcer, but often let his temper and behavior do more damage than his actual blocking.
4. Jay Cutler
His body language and dry sarcasm made it feel like he was above it all. Too bad his numbers and playoff record didn’t back it up.
3. Antonio Brown (post-Steelers)
He never stopped talking—even after he stopped producing. His mouth kept running long after his route tree did.
Read More: Coach White Fires Back at Cunningham Comments After Loss
2. Eli Apple
Few corners chirp like Eli Apple, and few get cooked as consistently. Opposing receivers practically took turns embarrassing him.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Best Trash Talkers in NFL History
1. Rex Ryan (honorary mention for a coach)
Yes, he’s a coach, but he talked like he was strapping on a helmet himself. His teams rarely lived up to his endless bravado—except maybe that one magical Jets run.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
