Some quarterbacks fade into history. Others? They live rent-free in fans’ minds forever, long after retirement or irrelevance sets in.
These are the guys fans will defend to the death—no matter what the stats say, how long it’s been, how many haters are yelling. Whether it’s nostalgia, loyalty, or just plain stubbornness, these quarterbacks still have armies of believers ready to argue on their behalf at the drop of a hat.
15. Jeff Garcia
He was never the flashiest name on the marquee, but fans in San Francisco and Cleveland still ride for him. Garcia had grit, attitude, and just enough chaos to make him unforgettable.
14. Tony Romo
Say one bad thing about Romo, and a Cowboys fan will materialize out of thin air to defend his honor. His playmaking magic—and infamous heartbreaks—cemented his spot in football lore.
13. Jake Plummer
Jake “The Snake” had an edge that fans absolutely loved. Denver and Arizona supporters still think he was one of the most underrated gunslingers of his era.
12. Randall Cunningham
He was electric, ahead of his time, and could do things most QBs only dreamed about. Fans who watched him in his prime still talk about him like he’s a superhero.
11. Boomer Esiason
Boomer had a cannon, confidence, and charisma that left a lasting impression. Bengals fans from the ’80s and ’90s still swear he had what it took to go all the way.
10. Donovan McNabb
Eagles fans are nothing if not loyal—and McNabb is one of their most beloved rollercoaster rides. Despite the ups and downs, plenty of Philly faithful still believe he never got the credit he deserved.
9. Steve McNair
Toughness personified, McNair earned deep respect from Titans fans and beyond. His ability to play through pain and keep his team in games made him a fan favorite for life.
8. Jim Kelly
He never won the big one, but that hasn’t stopped Bills fans from putting him on a pedestal. Kelly’s leadership during Buffalo’s Super Bowl run made him a legend in Western New York.
7. Jay Cutler
Yes, really—there’s a fiercely loyal group of Cutler defenders out there. Despite his aloof vibe, Bears fans saw the raw talent and still wish he had a better supporting cast.
6. Andrew Luck
He retired early, but Colts fans still daydream about what could’ve been. Luck’s brains, toughness, and awkward charm have kept him in their hearts ever since.
5. Phil Simms
Giants fans still talk about that near-perfect Super Bowl performance like it happened yesterday. Simms didn’t always get the headlines, but his clutch moments earned lifelong loyalty.
4. Warren Moon
Moon’s game was smooth, his arm was elite, and he made history along the way. Fans of the Oilers and football purists still gush about how he lit up the league.
3. Brett Favre
Sure, things got messy off the field and even on it at times—but the passion never faded. Packers fans (and even a few Vikings ones) still romanticize his wild, backyard-style football.
Read more: 25 Fan Bases That Somehow Think They’re the Underdog
2. Michael Vick
No quarterback divided opinion quite like Vick, but his supporters have never wavered. The speed, the arm, and the pure electricity still have fans in awe.
Read more: 20 Sports Stars Who Seemed to Have Zero Haters
1. Joe Namath
He guaranteed a Super Bowl win and delivered—and that was enough to earn lifelong love. Jets fans still treat him like royalty, even if his stats don’t always hold up to modern standards.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
