In the world of gaming, popularity doesn’t always equate to universal acclaim. Some of the most talked-about titles have sparked debate among players, receiving both accolades and criticism.
This list delves into ten such games that, despite their widespread recognition, have left players divided over their true merit and lasting impact.
10. Death Stranding
Death Stranding, Hideo Kojima’s 2019 post-apocalyptic delivery simulator, divides critics with its unique gameplay. While praised for stunning visuals and star-studded cast, many find its core mechanics tedious and story convoluted. Despite its ambition, the game’s slow pacing and repetitive tasks may not appeal to all players seeking engaging gameplay experiences.
9. Hades
While Hades received widespread acclaim, some argue it’s overhyped. Critics point to repetitive gameplay loops and limited enemy variety. Despite innovative storytelling, the roguelike structure may not appeal to all players. Its difficulty curve can also be frustrating for casual gamers seeking a more relaxed experience.
8. Animal Crossing: New Horizons
While beloved by many, New Horizons’ repetitive dialogue and lack of villager personality have drawn criticism. The game’s focus on island customization overshadows the social aspects that made previous entries charming. Despite updates, some players find the gameplay loop becomes tedious after extended play.
7. Minecraft
While Minecraft’s creativity and open-world gameplay have captivated millions, its popularity may overshadow its limitations. With 174 million active monthly users in 2023, the game’s simplistic graphics and repetitive gameplay can become monotonous for some. Despite its educational potential, critics argue that Minecraft’s widespread acclaim outweighs its actual entertainment value for many players.
6. Red Dead Redemption 2
While Red Dead Redemption 2 boasts stunning visuals and a vast open world, its slow pacing and tedious gameplay mechanics can be off-putting. The game’s realism often comes at the expense of fun, with lengthy animations and excessive micromanagement. Despite critical acclaim, some players find the experience more of a chore than an enjoyable adventure.
5. Fortnite
Despite its massive player base, Fortnite’s popularity may outweigh its merits. While it boasts impressive numbers, with over 250 million active players in February 2025, the game’s repetitive gameplay and microtransaction-heavy model have drawn criticism. Its cultural impact often overshadows discussions about its actual quality as a game.
4. Elden Ring
While Elden Ring’s open world and challenging combat garnered critical acclaim, some players find it overhyped. The game’s vast map can feel empty, with repetitive dungeons and reused bosses. Its difficulty may alienate casual gamers, and the narrative remains obscure for many. Despite its strengths, Elden Ring’s flaws are often overlooked in its praise.
3. Cyberpunk 2077
Despite its impressive visuals and immersive world, Cyberpunk 2077 fails to deliver on its promise of being a truly next-gen open-world experience. The game’s linear narrative and inability to accommodate player choices, particularly when it comes to playing as a villain, limit its roleplaying potential. Even after numerous updates, Night City still feels shallow compared to its initial hype.
Read More: The Best Video Game Companies That No Longer Exist
2. The Last of Us Part II
While praised for its graphics and performances, The Last of Us Part II divided players with its controversial narrative choices and bleak tone. Some felt the game’s violence was excessive and the story betrayed beloved characters. Despite critical acclaim, user reviews were mixed, with many longtime fans expressing disappointment in the direction taken.
Read More: Ready for Adventure? 10 Games Like Skyrim You Can Play Right Now
1. Grand Theft Auto V
Despite its massive popularity, GTA V’s single-player story feels shallow compared to earlier entries. The online mode, while expansive, is plagued by microtransactions and grind. The game’s satirical elements often miss the mark, relying on dated stereotypes. While technically impressive, GTA V fails to innovate meaningfully on its predecessors.
Read More: The Best Video Game Sequels Ever Made
