Being an NFL quarterback isn’t for the faint of heart. You’ve got 300-pound defenders gunning for you, armchair analysts dissecting your every throw, and the weight of an entire franchise resting on your shoulders. It’s a high-stakes job—but beyond the stats, wins, and highlight-reel throws, there’s another battle every QB faces: winning over the fans.
Some quarterbacks are beloved no matter what. Others? Let’s just say their PR departments have their work cut out for them. So, in the most unscientific way possible, we’re ranking all 32 starting quarterbacks from the 2024 season based on pure likeability. No film study, no analytics—just straight-up vibes. Let’s get into it!
32. Deshaun Watson
Yeah… no surprises here. Watson’s off-field controversies have tanked his reputation, making him one of the most disliked quarterbacks in the league. Even if he lights up the field, it’s hard for many fans to separate the player from the headlines. Browns fans may try to defend him, but for most of the NFL world, he’s an easy choice for the bottom of this list.
31. Aaron Rodgers
Some see Rodgers as a free thinker, a guy who marches to the beat of his own drum. Others see him as the NFL’s resident conspiracy theorist, always ready to stir the pot. His talent is undeniable, but his outspoken takes—on everything from vaccines to ayahuasca—have made him one of the most polarizing figures in the league. Love him or roll your eyes at him, Rodgers doesn’t care either way.
30. Will Levis
First impressions matter, and chugging mayo-infused coffee was not the way to win over the masses. Levis came into the league with a cannon for an arm and a chip on his shoulder, but his brash confidence could make him a love-him-or-hate-him type of QB. He’s still an unknown at the pro level, so the jury’s out—but for now, he’s more meme than superstar.
29. Kyler Murray
There’s no denying Kyler’s raw talent—when he’s on, he’s electric. But questions about his leadership, work ethic, and very publicized gaming habits have made him a lightning rod for criticism. When your contract includes a study clause (even if it was later removed), it raises eyebrows. Add in his sometimes icy demeanor, and it’s easy to see why Murray’s likeability isn’t exactly sky-high.
28. Daniel Jones
Danny Dimes? More like Danny Dubious. Despite starting most of the season, Jones has struggled to shake off the reputation of being that guy who face-planted on an 80-yard run. His flashes of brilliance are overshadowed by inconsistency, and while he’s not exactly unlikable, he’s also not doing much to win over the masses.
27. Russell Wilson
There was a time when Russ was one of the most beloved QBs in the league. But then came the cringeworthy social media moments, the Let’s Ride disaster, and a rocky stint in Denver that made him feel more like a meme than a superstar. His on-field play has dipped, and so has his likeability. If he can turn back the clock and start winning again, maybe he can win back the fans—but for now, the vibe check isn’t in his favor.
26. Dak Prescott
Dak is the ultimate love-him-or-hate-him quarterback. If you’re a Cowboys fan, he’s a high-character leader who does everything right off the field. If you’re not a Cowboys fan, he’s just another overhyped Dallas QB who can’t get it done in the playoffs. His likeability takes a hit every time the Cowboys fall short in January, but his leadership keeps him from sinking too far down this list.
25. Drake Maye
Maye showed flashes of promise, but he didn’t exactly take the league by storm. He’s got the talent, but his personality? Still a bit of a mystery. Without any major controversies or viral moments—good or bad—he’s just kind of there for now. If he starts lighting up defenses, his stock will rise, but until then, he’s flying under the radar in the likeability department.
24. Derek Carr
Carr is the definition of solid—but solid doesn’t always get people talking. He’s a respected veteran, a good teammate, and a stand-up guy, but he’s never been the most exciting player on or off the field. He’s likable in a dad-at-a-barbecue kind of way—safe, reliable, but not exactly thrilling. Fans respect him, but few are rushing to buy his jersey.
23. Caleb Williams
The NFL’s newest QB enigma. Williams is clearly talented, smart, and driven, but he’s already sparking debate before taking a single pro snap. Some see him as the next big thing, others aren’t sold on his attitude or confidence. As his personality and play unfold on the big stage, he could soar up this list—or slide down fast. For now, he’s a wildcard.
22. Bo Nix
Broncos fans weren’t sure what to expect from Nix, but he wasted no time making an impact. Leading Denver to its first playoff appearance in a decade is no small feat, and it’s already winning him plenty of fans. He’s not a household name just yet, but if he keeps this up, his likeability—and star power—will only rise.
21. Brock Purdy
Going from Mr. Irrelevant to leading one of the NFL’s top teams? That’s the kind of underdog story fans love. Purdy has earned respect with his poise and performance, but he’s still somewhat of a mystery off the field. He doesn’t stir up controversy, but he also hasn’t shown a ton of personality. If he starts showing more swagger—or racks up more playoff wins—his likeability could skyrocket.
20. Baker Mayfield
Once one of the most polarizing QBs in the league, Baker has reinvented himself as the scrappy underdog who just won’t quit. His fiery attitude and willingness to bet on himself have turned skeptics into fans, and his resurgence in Tampa only adds to the story. He still has his haters, but there’s no denying he’s become one of the league’s more compelling characters.
19. Justin Herbert
Herbert isn’t flashy, loud, or constantly in the headlines—but that’s part of his appeal. He’s a laid-back, introverted guy who lets his play do the talking. Those who follow him closely know he’s got a sneaky sense of humor, but he mostly keeps a low profile off the field. His talent is undeniable, and while he may not be the most charismatic QB, he’s got plenty of respect.
18. Geno Smith
Geno’s NFL journey is the definition of resilience. After years as a backup, he finally got his shot—and made the most of it. His resurgence in Seattle was one of the league’s best feel-good stories, turning him from an afterthought into a respected starter. He’s not the flashiest name on this list, but his perseverance and underdog mentality have won over plenty of fans. Let’s see how he does in Vegas!
17. Anthony Richardson
Richardson brings a mix of elite athleticism and infectious charisma that makes him hard not to root for. He’s got the talent, the confidence, and the playmaking ability to be a future star. Fans love his energy both on and off the field, and while he’s still raw, his upside is undeniable. If he keeps progressing, he could climb even higher on this list.
15. Bryce Young
Bryce Young hasn’t made waves off the field—good or bad—but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. He carries himself with poise, stays out of drama, and has the talent to back it up. His cool demeanor under pressure and promising future make him easy to root for. While he’s still finding his footing in the league, he hasn’t given anyone a reason not to like him yet.
15. Sam Darnold
Darnold may not be a superstar, but he’s got something just as valuable—likeability. After bouncing around the league, he finally found a way to win over fans with his resilience and humble attitude. His playoff struggles showed his limitations, but they didn’t diminish the respect he earned this past season. He’s proof that you don’t have to be elite to be easy to root for.
14. Gardner Minshew
The mustache. The jorts. The unapologetic swagger. Minshew is the ultimate vibes guy—a true cult hero wherever he goes. He may be a journeyman, but his fun-loving nature and eccentric personality make him one of the league’s most entertaining players. Whether he’s slinging passes or riding the bench, he brings an energy that fans can’t get enough of. He’s the kind of QB you’d love to grab a beer with, even if he’s not leading your team to the Super Bowl.
13. Matthew Stafford
Stafford has seen it all—from years of grinding in Detroit to finally hoisting a Lombardi with the Rams. He’s never been flashy, never sought the spotlight, but his toughness, leadership, and no-nonsense attitude have earned him universal respect. His Super Bowl win only solidified his legacy, making him even more likable. He’s the definition of a veteran who just puts his head down and gets the job done.
12. Patrick Mahomes
Whether you love him or love to root against him, there’s no denying Mahomes is the guy in today’s NFL. His talent is generational, his highlight-reel plays are endless, and he’s already building a dynasty in Kansas City. While some fans are tired of seeing him win, Mahomes himself stays humble, always showing love for his teammates, family, and city. He may be polarizing, but he’s undeniably one of the league’s most respected stars.
11. Jared Goff
Goff went from being cast off by the Rams to leading the Lions’ resurgence, and fans love him for it. He’s got that underdog edge, a laid-back but hilarious personality, and the toughness to shake off doubters. Detroit has fully embraced him, and his ability to thrive after being written off has earned him serious respect across the league. He may not be the flashiest QB, but he’s one of the easiest to root for.
10. Jordan Love
Taking over for a Packers legend like Aaron Rodgers? Nearly impossible. But Love has handled it with patience, humility, and a quiet confidence that’s winning fans over fast. After years of waiting in the wings, he’s proving he was worth the investment, and people love an underdog who rises to the challenge. If he keeps trending upward, his likeability—and legacy—will only grow.
9. Trevor Lawrence
With his signature flowing locks and effortless talent, Trevor Lawrence looks like he stepped straight out of a football movie. But he’s more than just Sunshine—his steady growth as a leader and playmaker has made him the face of the Jaguars’ resurgence. Humble, hardworking, and quietly charismatic, he’s winning over fans, even if his off-field personality is still a work in progress. If he keeps trending upward, he won’t just be a Jacksonville favorite—he’ll be an NFL star.
8. C.J. Stroud
Stroud carries himself like a 10-year vet—cool, confident, and completely unshakable. But what makes him so likable is that his confidence never feels like arrogance. He’s a natural leader, stays composed under pressure, and has already proven he can thrive in big moments. His rapid rise and humble demeanor have earned him serious respect, and if he keeps this up, he might climb even higher on this list.
7. Jayden Daniels
Daniels wasted no time winning fans over in his rookie season. His electric playmaking ability has already drawn comparisons to some of the league’s best, but what really sets him apart is his humble, hard-working attitude. He doesn’t just rely on raw talent—he puts in the work, and it shows. If he keeps progressing, he won’t just be one of the most likable QBs—he’ll be one of the best.
6. Kirk Cousins
“You like that?!” Yes, Kirk, we really do. With his wholesome dad-joke energy, self-aware personality, and genuine leadership, Cousins has become one of the most endearing QBs in the league. He may not have finished the season as a starter, and his future is uncertain, but Captain Kirk has already cemented himself as a fan favorite. Whether he’s rocking chains on the team plane or delivering clutch performances, it’s hard not to root for him.
5. Lamar Jackson
Lamar isn’t just one of the most electrifying players in the league—he’s also one of the most genuine. Whether he’s torching defenses on the field or cracking jokes on social media, he keeps it real. No ego, no drama—just pure love for the game, his teammates, and the city of Baltimore. His loyalty, work ethic, and unshakable confidence make him one of the most respected and likable QBs in the NFL.
4. Joe Burrow
Joe Cool lives up to his nickname in every way. He’s got the confidence of a superstar, but without the arrogance, making him the perfect mix of swagger and humility. Whether he’s rocking bold pregame fits or delivering clutch performances, Burrow just gets it. Add in his underdog journey from injury setbacks to franchise savior, and it’s no wonder he’s one of the most beloved QBs in the league.
3. Tua Tagovailoa
Tua might just be the easiest QB to root for. He’s humble, hardworking, and carries himself with the kind of kindness that makes you want to shield him from every internet troll. But don’t mistake his niceness for weakness—his resilience through injuries and adversity has been nothing short of inspiring. Whether it’s bouncing back from setbacks or proving doubters wrong, Tua keeps fighting with a smile on his face.
Related: 15 NFL Running Backs Who Changed the Game Forever
2. Jalen Hurts
Unshakable, unbothered, and undeniably elite—Jalen Hurts carries himself like a seasoned vet. He lets his play do the talking, never gets rattled, and leads with quiet confidence. And let’s be real—his suit game alone could land him near the top of this list. On and off the field, he commands respect, making him one of the most admired young QBs in the league.
Related: 15 NFL Stadiums You Must See in Your Lifetime
1. Josh Allen
Big, goofy, and built like a linebacker playing quarterback, Josh Allen is impossible not to love. He plays the game with reckless abandon, hurdling defenders and bulldozing linebackers like he’s in a backyard brawl. Off the field, he’s just as entertaining—whether it’s his hilarious interviews, top-tier bromance with Mahomes, or genuine love for Buffalo. He’s the kind of QB fans dream of—tough, talented, and always having fun.
Related: Ranking the 15 NFL Teams Who Need a Super Bowl Win Most
