Ranking the 20 Biggest Steals of the 2025 NFL Draft

The 2025 NFL Draft wasn’t just deep—it was a goldmine for teams that actually knew what they were doing. With so much talent slipping into the later rounds, it felt like half the league was stumbling into future starters while the other half sat there confused.

From surprise quarterback falls to superstar defenders getting picked way later than they should have, this draft was full of highway robbery. Here’s a look at the 20 biggest steals from the 2025 NFL Draft, based on where they went, how good they are, and how much they’re about to make other teams regret passing on them.

20. Devin Neal, RB, New Orleans Saints (Round 6, Pick 184)

Devin Neal racked up video-game numbers at Kansas, but somehow fell all the way to the sixth round. The Saints gladly scooped up a back who could easily carve out a big role sooner rather than later.

19. Cameron Williams, OL, Philadelphia Eagles (Day 3)

Cameron Williams was a top-100 talent hiding out on Day 3 like he was undercover. The Eagles added yet another future starter to their already ridiculous offensive line factory.

18. Dillon Gabriel, QB, Cleveland Browns (Round 3)

The Browns added another cannon arm to their QB room with Dillon Gabriel, a guy who threw for miles in college. If he clicks, Cleveland just found itself a real wild card.

17. Darius Alexander, DT, New York Giants (Round 3)

Darius Alexander was supposed to go higher but somehow landed in the Giants’ lap. He’s a disruptive force who could quickly turn into a starter up front.

16. Jihaad Campbell, LB, Philadelphia Eagles (Round 1)

Sure, he technically went in Round 1, but Jihaad Campbell had top-15 talent written all over him. Philly stole a future defensive anchor without even needing to trade up.

15. Will Johnson, CB, Arizona Cardinals (Round 2)

Will Johnson had first-round hype but dropped to Arizona in Round 2 like a gift from the draft gods. He’s got “future lockdown corner” written all over him.

14. Billy Bowman Jr., S, Atlanta Falcons (Round 4, Pick 118)

Billy Bowman Jr. was flying around at Oklahoma and somehow lasted until the fourth round. Atlanta may have just found a starter for pennies on the dollar.

13. Jaydon Blue, RB, Dallas Cowboys (Round 5)

Jaydon Blue turned the end zone into his personal vacation home at Texas. Dallas snagged him late, and he could become a serious threat in that offense.

12. Donovan Ezeiruaku, EDGE, Dallas Cowboys (Round 2, Pick 44)

Donovan Ezeiruaku was supposed to sneak into the first round but slipped a little too far. Now Dallas has a pass-rusher with serious upside who’s probably mad at the world.

11. Nick Emmanwori, S, Seattle Seahawks (Round 2, Pick 35)

Nick Emmanwori was projected to go way earlier but somehow dropped into Seattle’s lap. Expect him to immediately start lighting people up in the secondary.

10. Cameron Skattebo, RB, New York Giants (Round 4, Pick 105)

Cameron Skattebo’s tough, versatile style was worth way more than a fourth-round pick. The Giants may have found the fan favorite they’ve been missing.

9. D.J. Giddens, RB, Indianapolis Colts (Round 5, Pick 151)

D.J. Giddens is a bruising, athletic back who feels tailor-made for Indy’s offense. Getting him in Round 5 feels like an absolute heist.

8. Trey Amos, CB, Washington Commanders (Round 2, Pick 61)

Trey Amos wasn’t supposed to last until pick 61, but Washington isn’t complaining. He’s physical, smart, and ready to make an impact from Day 1.

7. Jack Sawyer, EDGE, Pittsburgh Steelers (Round 4)

Jack Sawyer fell into Pittsburgh’s hands, and you just know they’ll turn him into a sack machine. Former five-star recruits dropping to Day 3 is how dynasties get built.

6. Tory Horton, WR, Seattle Seahawks (Round 5, Pick 166)

Tory Horton has size, great hands, and top-100 talent, yet somehow lasted until pick 166. Seattle stole a legit weapon for their passing attack.

5. Luther Burden III, WR, Chicago Bears (Round 2, Pick 39)

Luther Burden was supposed to hear his name on Thursday night, not Friday. The Bears got a dynamic after-the-catch monster at an absolute bargain.

4. Will Howard, QB, Pittsburgh Steelers (Round 6, Pick 185)

Will Howard led the Big Ten in passing and brought home a national title, but nobody called his name until Round 6. Pittsburgh quietly grabbed a proven winner who could surprise everyone.

3. Shavon Revel Jr., CB, Dallas Cowboys (Round 3, Pick 76)

Shavon Revel Jr. was called by some the best cornerback in the draft, yet Dallas scooped him in Round 3. If he stays healthy, it’s lights out for opposing wideouts.

2. Mike Green, EDGE, Baltimore Ravens (Round 2, Pick 59)

Mike Green terrorized quarterbacks all season and still slipped into the late second round. Baltimore did what they always do—found an elite pass rusher while everyone else overthought it.

1. Shedeur Sanders, QB, Cleveland Browns (Round 5, Pick 144)

Shedeur Sanders falling to the fifth round felt like a glitch in the matrix. Cleveland now has a legit future franchise quarterback just chilling behind the scenes, waiting to take over.