Some players are just built differently—so likable, so electric, or so heartwarming that even rival fans couldn’t help but cheer for them. These are the guys who got standing ovations in visiting ballparks, whose jerseys were worn outside their home cities, and who somehow made baseball feel a little more fun.
Whether it was their hustle, humility, or just that infectious grin, these players transcended team loyalty. You didn’t have to root for their franchise to root for them—they were the kind of athletes who made you love the game a little more.
25. David Eckstein
He wasn’t the biggest guy on the field, but he hustled like every game was his last. Fans couldn’t help but admire the scrappy underdog energy.
24. Tony Gwynn
Gwynn was a pure hitter with a pure heart. His joy for the game made him impossible to dislike—even if he was racking up hits against your team.
23. Sean Casey
Known as “The Mayor,” Casey was as friendly as he was clutch. Everyone who met him said he was the nicest guy in baseball—and fans believed it.
22. Bartolo Colón
Big Sexy was baseball’s favorite unlikely hero. Whether he was lobbing fastballs or shocking the world with a home run, everyone was smiling.
21. Billy Butler
Country Breakfast had a bat and a nickname that brought people together. He was just a lot of fun, and fans loved him for it.
20. Curtis Granderson
Granderson played the game with class and charisma. Even if he torched your team, you found yourself nodding in respect.
19. Torii Hunter
Hunter’s highlight-reel catches and easygoing personality made him a fan favorite everywhere he went. He made center field look fun and fearless.
18. Ken Griffey Jr.
The backwards hat, the swing, the smile—Griffey was the poster child for cool. Every kid wanted to be him, and every fan loved watching him.
17. Ozzie Smith
The Wizard dazzled with defense and charmed with his backflips. He made the impossible look easy, and the crowd always ate it up.
16. Ichiro Suzuki
Ichiro had grace, style, and a quiet determination that made him magnetic. You didn’t have to speak Japanese to understand how great he was.
15. David Ortiz
Big Papi had a big bat and an even bigger heart. He was clutch, lovable, and always the life of the dugout.
14. Tim Lincecum
The Freak looked like a college kid but pitched like a legend. His funky mechanics and humble vibe made him universally adored.
13. Jim Thome
Thome crushed homers and still managed to feel like your neighborhood dad. He played the game right and never made it about himself.
12. Roy Halladay
Halladay was a workhorse with a quiet intensity that earned the respect of everyone. He didn’t need flash—just dominance and humility.
11. Mark Buehrle
Buehrle worked fast, threw strikes, and never made a fuss. He was the kind of guy fans across the league wished were on their team.
10. Jose Altuve (pre-scandal)
Before the sign-stealing drama, Altuve was baseball’s feel-good story. At 5’6”, he inspired fans everywhere with his heart and hustle.
9. Vladimir Guerrero
Vlad Sr. could hit anything, and fans loved him for it. Whether it bounced or blazed, he swung with joy and crushed with power.
8. Anthony Rizzo
Rizzo was a leader, both on and off the field, possessing an everyman charm. Cubs fans loved him, but so did pretty much everyone else.
7. Joey Votto
Votto was quirky, dryly hilarious, and sneaky brilliant. His interviews alone won people over, even when he was taking your ace deep.
6. Clayton Kershaw
Kershaw’s dominance came with humility and heart. Even rival fans rooted for him to get his World Series ring finally.
5. Mookie Betts
Mookie’s talent was obvious, but his energy and positivity made him beloved. He played with joy and always seemed to be having a blast.
4. Andrew McCutchen
Cutch was the face of Pittsburgh and the heart of baseball. His smile, swagger, and community spirit made him a favorite far beyond the Steel City.
3. Buster Posey
Posey led with quiet confidence and always carried himself like a pro. Even non-Giants fans respected his greatness and grace.
Read More: 20 Golfers Who Were Class Acts On and Off the Course
2. Shohei Ohtani
A once-in-a-century talent with a humble attitude? Yeah, fans from every corner of the league are still in awe of Ohtani.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Under-Appreciated MLB Stars of All Time
1. Jackie Robinson
Robinson broke barriers and inspired generations. You didn’t just root for Jackie—you honored him.
Read More: 25 MLB Stars You’d Want as a Neighbor
