Baseball might be a team sport, but sometimes one bad apple can spoil the whole bunch. Whether it’s endless drama, public feuds, or just an all-around toxic vibe, these players made more headlines for turmoil than teamwork.
Some of them had undeniable talent, but their impact in the locker room was anything but positive. From locker room outbursts to teammates begging for trades, these are 20 MLB clubhouse cancers that truly shook their teams.
20. Brett Lawrie
Lawrie brought energy, sure, but it often crossed the line into chaos. His wild personality and inconsistent focus wore thin on teammates and coaches alike.
19. Vicente Padilla
Padilla had a reputation for being difficult both on and off the mound. Even his own teammates seemed unsure of when he might throw at someone—or why.
18. Yasiel Puig
Puig was electric on the field but erratic behind the scenes. His antics in the clubhouse made him a lightning rod for controversy in multiple cities.
17. Matt Garza
Garza was known for fiery arguments and finger-pointing, often clashing with teammates. He wasn’t afraid to call people out publicly, which rarely goes over well.
16. A.J. Pierzynski
Pierzynski was one of the most disliked players in the game—and not just by opponents. Teammates often found his abrasive style just as irritating as rivals did.
15. Milton Bradley
Bradley’s issues followed him to every team he joined. Explosive confrontations and off-field problems created a constant cloud of tension.
14. Carl Everett
Everett had strong opinions and wasn’t shy about sharing them—often loudly. His disagreements with teammates and management made him a clubhouse headache.
13. Tommy Pham
Pham always speaks his mind, but sometimes that honesty spills into hostility. Whether it’s slapping a guy over fantasy football or calling out teammates, he keeps things spicy in the worst way.
12. Manny Ramirez
Manny being Manny was fun—until it wasn’t. His aloof attitude and frequent distractions often clashed with team chemistry.
11. Jeff Kent
Kent had a Hall of Fame-worthy bat and an ego to match. His frosty relationships with teammates (including a certain left fielder) became legendary.
10. Jonathan Papelbon
Intensity is good until it leads to choking a teammate in the dugout. Papelbon’s fiery demeanor often burned bridges instead of motivating the room.
9. Kevin Brown
Brown was dominant on the mound and difficult everywhere else. Known for moodiness and clubhouse blowups, he wasn’t exactly beloved by peers.
8. Barry Bonds
Bonds’ talent was off the charts, but so was his attitude. The icy vibes in the Giants’ clubhouse often revolved around his diva behavior and demands.
7. Josh Donaldson
Donaldson brought swagger—and sometimes too much of it. Multiple teams grew tired of his confrontational energy and vocal criticisms.
6. J.D. Drew
Drew didn’t say much, and that was part of the problem. Teammates often questioned his passion and commitment, creating a cold and disconnected locker room presence.
5. Jose Canseco
Steroid confessions, wild accusations, and nonstop attention-seeking made Canseco a clubhouse nightmare. He was more focused on headlines than harmony.
4. Nyjer Morgan
Morgan’s alter ego, “Tony Plush,” was entertaining until it wasn’t. His outbursts, fights, and over-the-top antics wore out welcomes quickly.
Read More: The 10 Most Legendary Locker Rooms in MLB History
3. Carlos Zambrano
Zambrano had a short fuse and a long history of teammate dustups. His constant meltdowns made the Cubs’ clubhouse feel like a pressure cooker.
Read More: 15 MLB Veterans Who Always Mentored the Clubhouse
2. Alex Rodriguez
A-Rod was always at the center of something—controversy, ego wars, or scandal. His presence brought more drama than cohesion, especially in his early Yankee years.
Read More: 24 Baseball Legends Who Weren’t Exactly Clubhouse Favorites
1. Albert Belle
No one intimidated a clubhouse quite like Belle. His anger issues, media hostility, and general unapproachability made him a ticking time bomb wherever he went.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
