Some players leave the game as legends. Others hang around too long, make a mess on the way out, or just can’t help but tarnish their shine.
From clubhouse drama to late-career flops, these players didn’t exactly stick the landing. Whether it was bad timing, bad behavior, or just plain bad luck, they fumbled what could’ve been a spotless legacy.
15. Manny Ramirez
Manny being Manny was fun—until it wasn’t. His antics and suspensions turned a Hall of Fame-caliber career into a what-could-have-been conversation.
14. Ryan Braun
From MVP to PR nightmare, Braun’s fall was swift and dramatic. That PED scandal crushed his reputation more than any pitcher ever could.
13. Jose Canseco
Canseco had all the tools on the field—and all the chaos off it. His post-career tell-alls and Twitter rants made him more meme than legend.
12. Robinson Canó
Once one of the smoothest players in the game, Canó’s legacy took a big hit with two PED suspensions. Now he’s more of a cautionary tale than a Hall of Fame lock.
11. Alex Rodriguez
A-Rod’s numbers were insane, but so was the drama. Between the PED issues, media wars, and a bizarre comeback attempt, his reputation took plenty of hits.
10. Barry Bonds
The all-time home run king couldn’t escape the cloud over his career. Bonds was unstoppable at the plate, but the whispers—and later shouts—about steroids never stopped.
9. Curt Schilling
Schilling delivered in the postseason, but his post-retirement persona has been a mess. From social media meltdowns to off-field controversies, he’s become more divisive than legendary.
8. Sammy Sosa
Sosa lit up baseball with his home runs and charisma, but things got weird after he left the game. Between the corked bat, the color change, and Hall of Fame exile, it’s been a strange ride.
7. Roger Clemens
Clemens was one of the most dominant pitchers ever, but his name is forever tied to steroids. That legacy stain has kept him out of Cooperstown and off plenty of best-of lists.
6. Miguel Tejada
Tejada was once an MVP and fan favorite, but his fall came fast. Between age fraud allegations and a PED suspension, he quietly faded out of the spotlight.
5. Yasiel Puig
Puig burst onto the scene with electric energy but couldn’t sustain it. Between inconsistent play and clubhouse issues, he became more frustrating than fascinating.
4. Rafael Palmeiro
The finger-pointing testimony before Congress will always be his legacy moment. And the failed drug test right after didn’t help much.
Read More: 17 NFL Stars Who Went From Heroes to Headaches
3. Josh Hamilton
Hamilton’s story had redemption written all over it—until the setbacks returned. Addiction struggles and legal issues clouded what should have been a triumphant tale.
Read More: 15 Tennis Stars Who Made Every Match About Their Legacy
2. Omar Vizquel
Once known for his smooth glove and quiet leadership, Vizquel’s post-career allegations shifted the spotlight entirely. What was once a likely Hall of Famer is now a player many want to forget.
Read More: 15 Baseball Divas Who Were Always the Center of Attention
1. Trevor Bauer
Bauer had the talent and the platform, but neither saved him from a massive reputation collapse. Off-field allegations and a messy fallout with MLB left him on the outside looking in, with a legacy few envy.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
