15 Former MLB Players Who Should Become Managers

Managing a Major League Baseball team is no easy task. It takes leadership, baseball IQ, and the ability to keep a clubhouse full of egos in check over a grueling 162-game season. Some of the best managers were once players themselves, and today’s game has plenty of former stars who seem destined to lead from the dugout.

From cerebral catchers to fiery infielders, here are 15 former MLB players who should throw on a manager’s cap and take charge of a team.

15. Torii Hunter

Torii Hunter was the ultimate clubhouse guy—full of energy, leadership, and, of course, incredible defensive highlights. He spent two decades in the majors, mentoring young players while still raking at the plate. His passion for the game and ability to connect with players would make him a perfect manager. Plus, who wouldn’t want to see him flashing that signature smile while arguing with umpires?

14. David Ross (Wait, Again?)

Okay, technically, David Ross already managed the Cubs, but just because one gig didn’t work out doesn’t mean he shouldn’t get another shot. He was beloved as a player, has championship experience, and still has the potential to succeed in the right situation. If he lands with a team that gives him more freedom, he could thrive in his next managerial role.

13. Jayson Werth

Jayson Werth always played with an edge, and you have to believe he’d bring that same fire to the dugout. He was a key part of a championship team, had a deep understanding of the game, and wasn’t afraid to speak his mind. His players would definitely have a manager who’s willing to go to bat for them—both figuratively and literally.

12. Joe Mauer

Joe Mauer was one of the smartest catchers to ever play, winning multiple batting titles while calling games behind the plate. He was the face of the Twins for over a decade, leading by example with a calm and collected demeanor. If he brought that same approach to managing, he could be the next great leader in Minnesota—or anywhere else that values a steady hand at the helm.

11. Mark Teixeira

Mark Teixeira had a sharp baseball mind, understood analytics, and always seemed to be one step ahead of the game. He played for multiple teams and was a key part of the Yankees’ 2009 World Series win. His ability to balance old-school fundamentals with modern-day strategy could make him a sneaky-good managerial candidate.

10. A.J. Pierzynski

A.J. Pierzynski was one of the most competitive and, let’s be honest, most annoying players to face in his prime. But that’s exactly the type of personality that could make for a great manager. He wasn’t afraid to ruffle feathers, he knew how to get under opponents’ skin, and he was a veteran leader in multiple clubhouses. If nothing else, his postgame interviews would be legendary.

9. Carlos Beltrán

Carlos Beltrán was already hired to manage the Mets before the sign-stealing scandal cost him the job before he even filled out a lineup card. But his baseball IQ is undeniable, and he’s respected throughout the league. He deserves another shot, and if given the right opportunity, he could become a great manager.

8. Dustin Pedroia

Dustin Pedroia played with a relentless motor and a deep love for the game. He was a clubhouse leader, constantly finding ways to elevate his teammates. If you don’t think he’d be an intense manager, just imagine him pacing the dugout, barking out instructions, and diving headfirst into an argument with an umpire. It feels inevitable that he’ll manage one day.

7. Jimmy Rollins

Jimmy Rollins was one of the smartest shortstops of his era, combining elite defensive skills with an ability to lead a clubhouse. He was the heart and soul of the Phillies for years and understood what it took to win at the highest level. With his experience, charisma, and baseball mind, he’d be a natural in the dugout.

6. Evan Longoria

Evan Longoria was a quiet but effective leader, anchoring the Rays and later the Giants as a respected veteran presence. He played the game the right way, always seemed to be in the right place at the right time, and had a sharp understanding of how to win. He’s the type of former player who could seamlessly transition into managing.

5. Buster Posey

Buster Posey was essentially a player-manager during his time with the Giants, controlling the game from behind the plate and guiding a pitching staff to multiple championships. He had the perfect mix of intelligence, leadership, and calmness under pressure. It wouldn’t be a shock if he ends up in a dugout one day calling the shots.

4. Yadier Molina

Yadier Molina might be the most obvious future manager in baseball. He was the ultimate field general as a catcher, working with pitchers, studying opponents, and leading the Cardinals with an unrivaled passion. His knowledge of the game is off the charts, and it’s only a matter of time before he steps into a manager’s role.

3. Chase Utley

Chase Utley was the ultimate competitor, playing with a level of intensity that made him one of the most respected and feared players of his generation. He was a silent assassin on the field, but his deep knowledge of the game and ability to lead by example make him an excellent candidate to be a manager. The only question is whether he’d ever want to deal with umpires every day.

2. CC Sabathia

CC Sabathia was a leader in every clubhouse he played in, mentoring younger pitchers while still dominating on the mound. He has a great personality, understands analytics, and has seen the game evolve over the years. A team looking for a fiery, passionate manager who can relate to modern players would be wise to give CC a call.

1. Albert Pujols

Albert Pujols is a living baseball encyclopedia. His career speaks for itself, but beyond the numbers, he was always a mentor and leader for young players. He understands hitting as well as anyone, knows how to handle pressure, and has the respect of everyone in the game. If he ever wants to manage, he’d likely have his pick of jobs.