Baseball is a beautiful game full of strategy, power, and occasionally, a lot of sass. And while hustling to first is technically part of the job description, some players seem way more interested in chirping at umps than sprinting out a grounder.
This list is for the guys who treat the batter’s box like a courtroom and the ump like a sworn enemy. Whether it’s a borderline strike call, a close play at first, or just general vibes, these players are never afraid to stop and debate before even considering breaking into a jog.
19. Joc Pederson
Joc’s got some pop, but he’s also got a mouth that doesn’t stay quiet when the count gets weird. He’ll stand there with his hands on his hips before thinking about heading down the line.
18. Yasmani Grandal
Grandal’s always had a reputation for being a vocal guy behind the plate—and he brings that same energy to the batter’s box. If he thinks the call was wrong, expect a dramatic pause and a full-on facial expression breakdown.
17. Joey Gallo
Gallo swings hard, misses big, and is not shy about questioning calls on the way back to the dugout and running to first on a soft dribbler. Not high on his priority list.
16. Javier Báez
Baez plays with flair and fire, and he’s never been one to go quietly. He’ll let the whole stadium know if he thinks he got hosed before even considering moving.
15. Yasiel Puig
Puig’s entire career has been chaotic, which extends to his interactions with umpires. If he doesn’t like the call, he’s ready for a theatrical performance before taking a step toward first.
14. Josh Donaldson
Donaldson doesn’t just argue—he lectures. He’s the guy who pauses to give a complete dissertation while the play continues behind him.
13. Nick Castellanos
Castellanos is great at turning bad news into an iconic moment, and he’s got the stare-down routine perfected. He’ll challenge a call with his eyes alone—and then maybe, jog to first.
12. Manny Machado
Machado can be electric, but he’s also famously uninterested in unnecessary effort. A borderline call? That’s a chance for some animated conversation, not a hustle highlight.
11. Francisco Lindor
Lindor has a smile, but don’t let that fool you—he’s got opinions. If he disagrees with a strike, he’ll give you the whole performance, with gesturing and lingering stares.
10. Kyle Schwarber
Schwarber’s strike zone debates are the stuff of legend, especially when he’s fired up. You can almost hear the umpire ducking for cover before Kyle starts jogging.
9. Anthony Rizzo
Rizzo’s the friendly guy with a not-so-friendly attitude regarding sketchy calls. He’ll smile at you while telling you exactly how wrong you are.
8. Nolan Arenado
Arenado brings the intensity, which means he doesn’t just play hard—he argues hard. He’s the kind of guy who forgets to run because he’s too busy making a point.
7. J.T. Realmuto
Realmuto’s known as one of the best catchers in the league, but even he gets testy when the strike zone gets weird. And when he does? That trip to first base can wait.
6. Carlos Correa
Correa has no problem telling everyone how he feels about a call—loudly and in detail. If he thinks he got wronged, expect arm-waving and delayed reactions.
5. Giancarlo Stanton
Stanton’s massive frame isn’t usually in a hurry, and arguing gives him another reason to take his time. Sometimes you wonder if he even knows first base is still there.
4. Brandon Belt
Belt has tracked bad calls against him, so he’s not letting anything slide. Running to first is never step one when he’s got a bone to pick.
3. Tim Anderson
Anderson plays with emotion and wears it all over his face, especially when he’s not a fan of the call. You’ll see the hands go up, the head shake, and a full delay of the game before he heads to first.
2. Trevor Bauer
Sure, he’s a pitcher, but you knew he’d turn it into a mini-drama when he got his rare plate appearances. And when he was on the mound? He still acted like the plate belonged to him.
Read More: The 10 Most Controversial NHL MVP Winners Ever
1. Bryce Harper
Harper has MVP talent and the soul of a full-time drama student. He’ll lock eyes with an ump like it’s a Western standoff before deciding whether first base is worth it.
Read More: 24 Athletes Who Would Absolutely Fight a Ref and Not Apologize
