Trash talk is an art form in baseball. But sometimes, what feels like a home run quote in the moment ends up looking like a big ol’ whiff when the dust settles.
From calling out rivals to proclaiming dynasties before even winning a division, these MLB players got way too comfortable running their mouths. Here are 25 guys whose trash talk didn’t just age poorly—it practically expired on the shelf.
25. Bryce Harper
He once said Philly would bring “multiple titles” during his time there. Still waiting on just one.
24. Yasiel Puig
Puig promised fireworks in Cincinnati and backed it up with… a decent brawl. His words had more power than his bat that season.
23. Nick Castellanos
He chirped about the Reds being the team to beat. Then the Reds promptly beat themselves out of contention.
22. Trevor Bauer
Bauer talked about “changing the culture” in multiple cities. Turns out, those cities weren’t interested in what he was selling.
21. Alex Rodriguez
A-Rod once claimed he’d redefine greatness. He did, just not the way he intended.
20. Jonathan Papelbon
He guaranteed playoff success when he joined the Phillies. What followed was an era of mediocrity and meltdowns.
19. Manny Machado
Machado told fans in San Diego they were building a “World Series team.” They’re still under construction.
18. Josh Donaldson
He made it clear he was bringing MVP-level play wherever he went. Unfortunately, he often left that level in the past.
17. José Canseco
He predicted massive success post-steroids era. What he delivered was a Twitter account and a boxing match.
16. Pete Alonso
Alonso called the Mets the “kings of New York.” Then they promptly ceded the throne to the Yankees—and the Braves.
15. Carlos Gómez
He trash talked opposing pitchers after singles like he hit grand slams. Eventually, pitchers just laughed as they struck him out.
14. Matt Harvey
Dubbed himself “The Dark Knight” and called out the media like Gotham’s savior. Gotham responded by trading him to the Reds.
13. Marcus Stroman
Never shy about chirping on social media. But his ERA often clapped back harder than the opponents ever could.
12. Chris Archer
Claimed he was the face of the Rays. The face quickly faded after a series of rough starts and trades.
11. Brian Wilson
Told everyone the Giants were unstoppable with him closing. Then he stopped closing.
10. Jason Kipnis
Mocked other teams’ rebuilds while Cleveland was peaking. A few years later, Cleveland was doing one of its own.
9. Brett Lawrie
Talked like he was the spark plug every team needed. Turned out to be more of a short circuit.
8. Billy Butler
After big words about becoming a Royals legend, he ended his career quietly in Oakland. Not exactly how legends are written.
7. Kevin Youkilis
Trash talked opposing pitchers constantly. Then his swing stopped making contact with anything but air.
6. Milton Bradley
Told anyone who’d listen that he was misunderstood greatness. Turns out, people just understood the strikeouts.
5. Delmon Young
Talked up his playoff clutch gene. Then, teams stopped giving him the chance to even show up in October.
4. Joba Chamberlain
Declared he’d dominate the AL East for years. The hitters had other plans.
3. Carlos Zambrano
Always quick to shout and call out others. But the most damage came from his own meltdowns.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Best Trash Talkers in NFL History
2. Jose Bautista
Flipped bats and talked big after homers. Then pitchers figured him out, and the bat flips stopped real quick.
Read More: 20 MLB Stars Who Turned Trash Talk Into a Personality Trait
1. Barry Zito
Called his Giants contract “just the beginning” of something special. What followed was a rough stretch that had Giants fans begging for the end.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
