You can tell a lot about someone by how they are as a neighbor. Are they friendly but not nosy? Do they keep the lawn looking sharp? Would they lend you a ladder—or better yet, invite you over for a cookout?
In the world of Major League Baseball, a few guys just give off that “great neighbor” energy. Whether it’s their attitude, vibe, or the sense they’d be fun to live next to, here are 25 MLB stars you’d definitely want living on your block.
25. Christian Yelich
Chill, polite, and likely to wave every morning. Feels like the type who’d quietly snow-blow your driveway just because.
24. Anthony Rizzo
Always down for a block party. He’s got the grill going, music playing, and probably a cooler full of drinks.
23. Julio Rodríguez
Young, energetic, and great with kids. He’s the neighbor that instantly becomes the favorite of everyone on the street.
22. Paul Goldschmidt
Respectful, low drama, and keeps to himself unless you need a hand. A true suburban MVP.
21. Alec Bohm
Friendly, approachable, and seems like the kind of guy who’d help you build a fence. Bonus points for being low-key hilarious.
20. José Ramírez
Bilingual and big-hearted, he’d bring a great sense of community. Plus, his backyard parties would be legendary.
19. Marcus Semien
Dependable, organized, and probably has a perfectly manicured lawn. You’d feel safer knowing he lives next door.
18. Joc Pederson
A little quirky, a lot of fun. You never know what costume or holiday lights he’ll put up, but it’s always entertaining.
17. Will Smith (Dodgers)
Calm, collected, and drama-free. Just a solid presence on the block who never makes a fuss.
16. Ronald Acuña Jr.
Loud in the best way. Always smiling, always hyping people up, and probably owns the best stereo system on the block.
15. Gerrit Cole
Smart, thoughtful, and probably gives great advice about lawn care or fantasy football. Your HOA would love him.
14. Kyle Schwarber
He’s that neighbor who always has tools, always has time, and always has cold beer. Just a good guy to have around.
13. Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Charismatic and fun-loving, he’s the guy who turns the street into a celebration. BBQs, fireworks, and maybe a Wiffle ball game or two.
12. Brandon Nimmo
Always smiling, always helpful. He’d be the first one to say hi to your dog and offer to bring in your mail.
11. Aaron Nola
Steady, quiet, and totally reliable. He’s probably got a great garden and always brings something homemade to the potluck.
10. Freddie Freeman
Polite, positive, and a natural leader. You just know he’d organize the best holiday decorating contests.
9. Byron Buxton
Chill but sneaky funny, and the type to help you move a couch without hesitation. Also, likely the fastest guy to help chase down your runaway pet.
8. Shohei Ohtani
International superstar, yes—but he seems incredibly humble and kind. Imagine telling people Shohei lives two doors down.
7. Justin Turner
With the beard and the big smile, he’s the neighborhood mayor. He knows everyone, hosts everything, and always brings good vibes.
6. José Altuve
Friendly and generous, Altuve’s the guy you’d call when your car won’t start—and he’d show up with jumper cables and a smile.
5. Max Muncy
The kind of guy who’d return your rake, edge your sidewalk, and invite you over for burgers—all in one afternoon.
4. Mookie Betts
Smooth, cool, and always respectful. He’s got a great playlist and even better stories if you can get him to hang out for a while.
3. Austin Riley
Classic southern hospitality. He’s the guy who always waves, keeps his yard perfect, and genuinely cares about the people around him.
2. Dansby Swanson
Clean-cut, personable, and would definitely show up to your kid’s lemonade stand. He gives “ideal neighbor” energy every day of the week.
Read More: 10 MLB Teams Stuck in Baseball Purgatory
1. Mike Trout
Trout just feels like the total package—humble, friendly, and effortlessly cool. He’d take your trash bins out, mow your lawn if you’re sick, and never, ever complain about noise.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Fun MLB Teams to Root For
