The 15 Most Polarizing NFL Players in History

The NFL has seen plenty of superstars, but not all of them were universally loved. Whether due to their on-field antics, off-field controversies, or larger-than-life personalities, these players divided fanbases like no other.

Here’s a ranking of the 15 most polarizing players in NFL history.

1. Tom Brady

The GOAT to some, a cheater to others. Brady’s dominance, combined with the “Deflategate” scandal and his connection to Bill Belichick, made him both admired and despised. Whether you love him or hate him, you can’t deny his impact.

2. Colin Kaepernick

Kaepernick’s decision to kneel during the national anthem sparked a nationwide conversation on race, police brutality, and patriotism. His stance made him a hero to many and a villain to others, ensuring his place as one of the most divisive figures in sports history.

3. Aaron Rodgers

Once seen as a lovable underdog, Rodgers’ transformation into an outspoken, sometimes contrarian figure has changed how fans perceive him. His views on COVID-19, vaccines, and media feuds have made him an NFL lightning rod.

4. Terrell Owens

T.O. was as famous for his touchdowns as he was for his celebrations, sideline antics, and locker room drama. He put up Hall of Fame numbers but often left teams in chaos, making him one of the league’s most entertaining and controversial figures.

5. Michael Vick

Vick’s electric playstyle made him a fan favorite—until his dogfighting scandal landed him in prison. His redemption arc divided fans, with some believing he paid his debt and others refusing to forgive him.

6. Antonio Brown

One of the most talented wide receivers of his era, Brown’s career has been overshadowed by erratic behavior, legal troubles, and abrupt exits from multiple teams. His talent was undeniable, but his off-field antics ensured he was always in the headlines.

7. Brett Favre

Favre was a gunslinger both on and off the field, thrilling fans with his improvisational play but frustrating them with his retirement flip-flops. His post-career controversies, including welfare fraud allegations, have only further divided public opinion.

8. O.J. Simpson

Simpson was once one of the most beloved figures in sports, but his legacy was forever changed by his infamous murder trial in 1995. Despite being acquitted in criminal court, he was later found liable in a civil case. His continued media presence and legal troubles have kept him one of the most polarizing figures in NFL history.

9. Ben Roethlisberger

Two Super Bowls cemented his legacy, but off-field allegations early in his career cast a long shadow. While Steelers fans adored him, many outside Pittsburgh never saw him as the face of the league.

10. Ndamukong Suh

Few defensive players were as feared—or as controversial—as Suh. His aggressive style, dirty plays, and multiple suspensions made him one of the most polarizing players of his time.

11. Cam Newton

Newton’s flashy style, Superman celebrations, and unique fashion sense made him a star, but his on-field demeanor rubbed some fans the wrong way. His refusal to dive for a loose ball in Super Bowl 50 remains a defining moment in his career.

12. Ray Lewis

A legendary linebacker and vocal leader, Lewis’ connection to a 2000 murder case (in which he pled guilty to obstruction of justice) is still a point of contention. His motivational speeches and faith-driven persona only added to his polarizing nature.

13. Tim Tebow

Few players have inspired as much debate as Tebow. His strong Christian faith, unconventional playing style, and die-hard fanbase made him a media sensation—even when his on-field performance didn’t always back it up.

14. Greg Hardy

Hardy’s domestic violence allegations and second chance in the NFL after a disturbing case made him one of the most disliked figures in league history. His brief attempt at an MMA career only added to the controversy.

15. Deion Sanders

“Prime Time” was a showman through and through, dazzling fans with his speed, confidence, and trash talk. Some saw him as an all-time great, while others thought he was more flash than substance. Either way, he never failed to entertain.