Some quarterbacks live for structure, discipline, and clean pockets. And then there are the ones who see chaos as an opportunity, not a threat—the gunslingers, the risk-takers, the human roller coasters.
This list is all about the most reckless quarterbacks the NFL has ever seen. Whether they were throwing into triple coverage, diving headfirst into a linebacker, or trying to make a miracle happen on every play, these guys were allergic to playing it safe.
19. Blake Bortles
Bortles was the king of YOLO throws and fourth-quarter stat padding. He’d make a jaw-dropping play one moment and a baffling decision the next.
18. Vince Young
Young trusted his legs a little too much and his reads a little too little. His highlight reel is wild—but so is the turnover count.
17. Carson Wentz
Early on, he looked like a franchise star. Then the recklessness took over, and the hero ball got out of control.
16. Jameis Winston
Winston could throw for 5,000 yards and 30 interceptions in the same season—because he literally did. His decision-making was always one giant gamble.
15. Johnny Manziel
Manziel played every down like he was still in college, trying to make something out of nothing. The NFL defenses weren’t impressed.
14. Jay Cutler
Cutler had a cannon and zero hesitation to use it. The problem was, he trusted his arm way more than he probably should have.
13. Drew Lock
Lock had swagger and a short memory—sometimes a little too short. Every throw felt like a coin flip between a touchdown and a disaster.
12. Tony Romo
Romo made magic happen on broken plays, but he also made plenty of head-scratching mistakes trying to extend them. High reward, high risk, always.
11. Ryan Fitzpatrick
“Fitzmagic” was thrilling and terrifying at the same time. You never knew if he’d throw four touchdowns or four picks, and sometimes both.
10. Josh Freeman
Freeman flashed star potential, but his confidence often led him into some seriously reckless territory. His play style was pure chaos in motion.
9. Colin Kaepernick
Kaepernick took chances other quarterbacks wouldn’t dream of. Sometimes it worked, sometimes it backfired spectacularly.
8. Rex Grossman
His nickname was literally “Rex Reckless” at one point. If you were open, he’d throw it—even if someone else was more open in the other jersey.
7. Michael Vick
Vick’s raw ability made him a threat to score on any play, but he didn’t always make the safest choices. His style was electric, erratic, and unpredictable.
6. Jake Plummer
Plummer had all the traits of a gunslinger and none of the hesitation. He lived for the big play, even when a short gain would’ve done just fine.
5. Zach Wilson
Wilson has made a habit of trying to do too much. The reckless plays haven’t stopped piling up, and neither has the criticism.
4. Jeff George
George had one of the best arms ever and used it to force some of the worst throws you’ve ever seen. He never saw a window he didn’t like.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Greatest Quarterbacks to Ever Play the Game
3. Baker Mayfield
Mayfield plays with a chip on his shoulder and the recklessness to match. He’s the type to force a throw just to prove a point.
Read More: 15 Throwback Linebackers Built for Today’s Game
2. Brett Favre
Favre is the blueprint for reckless quarterbacking, and he somehow made a Hall of Fame career out of it. He holds the interception record and probably doesn’t regret a single one.
Read More: 20 QBs Who Always Played Like It Was 3rd and 15
1. Tony Banks
Banks had a cannon for an arm and a complete disregard for caution. If there was a wild option, he was taking it—no questions asked.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
