Every NBA fan loves a good hype train, but not every player manages to stay on the tracks. For every LeBron James who exceeds expectations, a dozen others had all the buzz, all the commercials, and somehow, none of the results.
Sometimes it’s bad luck, sometimes injuries, and sometimes just that the skills everyone swore would change the league never fully materialized. No matter the reason, these 20 players left fans wondering what could’ve been instead of celebrating what was.
20. Michael Beasley
Michael Beasley had the game, the swagger, and the résumé to be a star, but he never quite figured out how to put it together. He had plenty of flashy moments, but consistency was always a stranger.
19. O.J. Mayo
O.J. Mayo was supposed to be the next big scorer, but he quickly became another guy on the roster. A solid start led to a steady decline, leaving everyone wondering what happened.
18. Kwame Brown
Kwame Brown had the honor of being the number one overall pick, but the burden of being called a bust almost immediately after. Despite carving out a long career, the expectations were too high.
17. Adam Morrison
Adam Morrison had legendary college highlights but looked lost when he stepped onto an NBA floor. His career became a classic example of “college dominance doesn’t always translate.”
16. Anthony Bennett
The only thing more shocking than Anthony Bennett going first overall was how quickly he flamed out. Every game felt like a reminder that maybe someone else should’ve gotten that call.
15. Darko Miličić
Darko Miličić is the cautionary tale every GM sees in their nightmares. Picked ahead of multiple future Hall of Famers, he spent most of his career riding the bench.
14. Hasheem Thabeet
Hasheem Thabeet was a towering presence who never figured out how to use his size effectively. His brief stints on multiple teams made him more of a trivia answer than a star.
13. Derrick Williams
Derrick Williams looked like he had everything — athleticism, size, and a flashy game — but none translated into real NBA success. His career became a string of “maybe this is the year” moments that never came.
12. Sebastian Telfair
Sebastian Telfair entered the NBA straight out of high school with significant buzz but struggled to find footing. He bounced around from team to team without finding a true home.
11. Marvin Williams
Marvin Williams went second overall in a loaded draft but never became a centerpiece. He was solid but not nearly the franchise-changer people were expecting.
10. Jimmer Fredette
Jimmer Fredette had fans believing he would light up NBA defenses like he did in college. However, he initially struggled with the league’s speed and physicality.
9. Tyreke Evans
Tyreke Evans had an incredible rookie season that made everyone think superstardom was around the corner. Instead, that first year became the clear peak of his career.
8. Greg Oden
Greg Oden might be the most sympathetic case on this list. Injuries stole what should’ve been a dominant career. Fans were left with glimpses of greatness that sadly never got to grow.
7. Stromile Swift
Stromile Swift was supposed to be an athletic marvel who could change the game, but he never quite figured out how to channel all that talent. He became known more for flashy dunks than real production.
6. Andrea Bargnani
Andrea Bargnani was hyped as a matchup nightmare who could shoot from anywhere, but he never became more than a role player. Toronto fans waited years for a breakout that never came.
5. Michael Olowokandi
Michael Olowokandi is one of those number one picks who immediately made you question the scouting process. His production never remotely matched the expectations that came with his draft slot.
4. Dennis Smith Jr.
Dennis Smith Jr.’s highlight-reel dunks and raw athleticism excited everyone. However, inconsistent play and struggles with team fit derailed what could’ve been a promising career.
3. Markelle Fultz
Markelle Fultz had all the tools to be the next superstar guard until mysterious injuries and shooting woes completely changed his career trajectory. He’s carved out a role, but the “what if” still looms.
2. Lonnie Walker IV
Lonnie Walker IV was supposed to be the next electric scorer with hops for days, but his career has been more flash than substance. Every breakout moment seemed to be followed by long stretches of inconsistency.
Read More: Ranking the Most Overrated Athletes Ever
1. Ben Simmons
Ben Simmons looked like the future of basketball but ended up being one of its most frustrating enigmas. His mix of unbelievable talent and hesitation has made his career one giant question mark.
Read More: 15 Times Sports Media Got the Hype Train Completely Wrong
