The world of the NFL is no stranger to controversy, especially when it comes to the firing and dismissal of prominent coaches.
These events often spark debates and discussions that resonate far beyond the field. Here are ten of the most shocking NFL coach firings and controversies that have left fans and analysts alike questioning decisions, loyalties, and the pressures of professional sports.
9. The Jets’ Mid-Season Firing of Robert Saleh (2024)
The New York Jets shocked the NFL by firing head coach Robert Saleh just five games into the 2024 season. Despite high expectations with Aaron Rodgers’ return, the team’s 2-3 start and ongoing offensive struggles led to Saleh’s dismissal. The abrupt decision sparked debate about patience in rebuilding and the pressure to win immediately in the NFL.
8. Mike McCarthy’s Green Bay Ouster
The Packers’ decision to fire Mike McCarthy in 2018 after 13 seasons sparked controversy. Despite a Super Bowl win and consistent playoff appearances, tensions with quarterback Aaron Rodgers and offensive stagnation led to his dismissal. McCarthy’s firing mid-season was unprecedented in Packers history, leaving fans divided on its timing and necessity.
7. Chip Kelly’s Abrupt Eagles Exit
Chip Kelly’s firing by the Philadelphia Eagles in 2015 stunned the NFL world. After three seasons and a 26-21 record, Kelly was dismissed just before the final game. His innovative offense had initially shown promise, but controversies over personnel decisions and allegations of racism ultimately led to his downfall. Kelly’s abrupt exit sparked intense debate about his coaching style and NFL future.
6. Sean Payton’s Suspension for “Bountygate”
In 2012, NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell suspended Saints head coach Sean Payton for the entire season without pay for his role in the “Bountygate” scandal. Payton was found to have known about and failed to stop a program that offered bounties to players for injuring opponents. This unprecedented punishment sparked intense debate about appropriate disciplinary measures for coaches.
5. Jon Gruden’s Email Scandal and Resignation
Jon Gruden resigned as Las Vegas Raiders head coach in 2021 after emails containing racist, homophobic, and misogynistic language surfaced. The emails, spanning from 2011 to 2018, were discovered during an NFL workplace misconduct investigation. Gruden’s sudden departure sparked discussions about accountability and inclusivity in professional sports.
4. Jim Harbaugh’s Departure from the 49ers
Jim Harbaugh’s exit from the 49ers in 2014 was controversial. Despite leading the team to three NFC Championship games and a Super Bowl appearance, tensions with management led to his departure. Harbaugh later revealed he was forced out, contradicting the “mutual” split narrative, highlighting the complex dynamics between successful coaches and front offices.
3. Doug Pederson’s Unexpected Firing After Super Bowl Win
The Philadelphia Eagles shocked the NFL world by firing Doug Pederson in 2021, just three years after he led them to their first Super Bowl victory. Pederson’s dismissal came after a 4-11-1 season and reports of a fractured relationship with quarterback Carson Wentz. The decision sparked debate about loyalty in the NFL and the short-lived nature of success.
Read More: The 15 Most Controversial F1 Drivers on and off the Track
2. The Patriots’ Shocking Dismissal of Jerod Mayo (2024)
Jerod Mayo’s firing after just one 4-13 season as Patriots head coach stunned the NFL world. Owner Robert Kraft admitted putting Mayo in an “untenable situation” as Bill Belichick’s successor. The swift dismissal, coming shortly after the team’s final game, raised questions about the franchise’s direction and commitment to long-term rebuilding.
Read More: The 10 Most Controversial NHL MVP Winners Ever
1. Urban Meyer’s Controversial Jaguars Tenure (2021)
Urban Meyer’s NFL coaching career lasted just 13 games with the Jacksonville Jaguars. Hired with high expectations, Meyer’s tenure was marred by controversies, including a viral video at a bar and allegations of player mistreatment. The Jaguars fired Meyer after a 2-11 start, sparking debates about his leadership and adaptability to the NFL.
Read More: These 10 College Football Coaches Aren’t as Great as You Think
