The NFL is filled with unforgettable characters, but sometimes being a fan of certain players felt like riding a roller coaster with a loose seatbelt. These were the guys who tested your patience, raised your blood pressure, and made you wonder why you ever picked up a jersey in the first place.
From endless drama to maddening inconsistency, these players were incredibly talented, but rooting for them felt like a full-time job. Whether it was off-field antics, locker room distractions, or game-day chaos, these 30 players made fandom feel more like endurance training.
30. Dez Bryant
When Dez was locked in, he was electric—but you never knew when the meltdown was coming. Between sideline blowups and frustrating injuries, it was rarely a calm ride.
29. Cam Newton
Cam brought MVP-level talent and fashion-forward chaos in equal measure. Some Sundays, he was superhuman, and others, you were just hoping his scarf wasn’t tighter than his spiral.
28. Ndamukong Suh
Elite on defense, but it was hard to cheer when he was always one step away from a fine or suspension. Watching him was like waiting for a penalty flag to drop every other snap.
27. Jay Cutler
No one mastered the art of the “I don’t care” face quite like Cutler. Even when he threw a beautiful touchdown, it somehow still looked like he hated being there.
26. Antonio Brown
AB went from generational receiver to walking headline in record time. Rooting for him meant constantly checking your phone in fear of what he’d done next.
25. Eli Apple
Talented? Sure. But his knack for getting torched right after talking trash made it exhausting to back him up.
24. Terrell Owens
T.O. made everything personal, from touchdown dances to press conferences. He could win you a game and lose your goodwill in the same quarter.
23. Johnny Manziel
Johnny Football was all hype and half delivery. You spent more time defending his “potential” than celebrating actual wins.
22. Baker Mayfield
Baker gives fans hope, quotes, and interceptions in equal measure. The chip on his shoulder’s almost bigger than his stat line.
21. Martavis Bryant
When he was on the field, he was a home-run threat. But rooting for him meant hoping he could stay eligible long enough to matter.
20. Michael Vick
Rooting for Vick was a moral and emotional tightrope. His comeback was compelling, but the baggage never quite left the building.
19. Odell Beckham Jr.
OBJ’s highlight reel catches were always worth the hype, but the off-field attention fatigue was very real. You loved him one week and questioned everything the next.
18. Randy Gregory
Every time he flashed his pass-rushing potential, the next headline was about a suspension. Fans had whiplash trying to keep up with his availability.
17. Josh Norman
He made defense entertaining, but sometimes it felt like he was more invested in the drama than the game. If you liked noise, he gave you plenty, but wins? Not always.
16. Sam Darnold
The talent’s there, but the turnovers are relentless. Rooting for him feels like holding out hope that’s never quite come.
15. Richie Incognito
He was mean, nasty, and good in the trenches—but the off-field stuff was always hanging over him. Supporting him meant explaining a lot more than just football.
14. Jameis Winston
He can throw for 400 yards and four touchdowns… and also four interceptions. It’s chaos football, and it drains the soul.
13. Percy Harvin
Harvin’s flashes of brilliance were matched only by his inconsistency and injuries. You never knew if he’d score or storm off the field.
12. Le’Veon Bell
When he was cooking, he was elite, but the contract drama and skipped seasons wore thin. Fans got tired of waiting for him to return to form.
11. Josh Gordon
It was impossible not to root for his redemption, but just when he’d get it going, it would all fall apart. The cycle became too familiar.
10. Carson Wentz
There were moments he looked like an MVP, and others when you questioned if he belonged in the league. Rooting for him was a yo-yo of belief and disappointment.
9. Greg Hardy
Hardy’s talent on the field was undeniable, but rooting for him felt gross. It was a tough sell from every angle.
8. Chad Johnson
He was hilarious, talented, and always a show, but sometimes the antics overwhelmed the actual performance. Fans had to hope the drama wouldn’t derail the game.
7. JaMarcus Russell
The potential was massive, but the execution was not. Supporting him meant ignoring red flags the size of a stadium.
6. Aaron Rodgers
Even when he was winning MVPs, he was exhausting. The passive-aggressive interviews, cryptic comments, and off-field drama made cheering for him a chore.
5. Kareem Hunt
From stardom to suspension and back, fans had to wrestle with rooting for talent wrapped in controversy. It never really got comfortable.
4. Tony Romo
One moment he was threading the needle for a touchdown, the next he was fumbling a snap to lose the playoffs. Cowboys fans still carry the emotional scars.
3. Terrelle Pryor
He kept reinventing himself, but none of the versions quite stuck. Fans were always chasing a version of him that never lasted.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Fun MLB Teams to Root For
2. Deshaun Watson
No matter how good he once was, rooting for him now feels more like damage control than fanhood. It’s hard to separate the player from the headlines.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Frustrating MLB Teams to Root For
1. Brett Favre
He retired, unretired, switched teams, and stirred drama at every turn. Being a Favre fan was a full-time job—one with no off-season and a ton of baggage.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Frustrating NFL Teams to Root For
