The NFL can be brutal on the field, but some players managed to do real damage to their careers away from it. Whether it was bad decisions, off-field drama, or just plain bad luck, these guys took the scenic route straight out of stardom.
Some had all the talent in the world but couldn’t stay out of their own way. From arrests to attitude problems to just forgetting football was a job, these 20 players dropped the ball where it mattered most—off the field.
20. Josh Gordon
One of the most naturally gifted wideouts in recent memory, Gordon couldn’t outrun his off-field issues. Despite multiple chances, suspensions kept piling up, and so did the missed opportunities.
19. Henry Ruggs III
Ruggs looked like a future star with his speed and upside, but one tragic mistake changed everything. A reckless decision off the field ended his career before it really got going.
18. Johnny Manziel
The hype was electric, but the lifestyle was even louder. Johnny Football became Johnny Distraction way too fast, and the league moved on.
17. Plaxico Burress
A Super Bowl hero who shot himself—literally and figuratively. One accidental discharge in a nightclub sent his career spiraling.
16. Ray Rice
Rice was a reliable back until one shocking incident was caught on video. The NFL might forgive, but the footage never forgets.
15. Aldon Smith
Smith could terrorize quarterbacks but couldn’t avoid personal demons. His rap sheet grew longer than his highlight reel.
14. Titus Young
Young had all the tools to thrive in the league, but quickly became his own worst enemy. On and off-field behavior issues had teams backing away fast.
13. Aaron Hernandez
This one goes beyond football into full-blown true crime territory. Hernandez threw away a promising career in one of the most infamous collapses the sport has ever seen.
12. Justin Blackmon
A top-five pick with elite potential, Blackmon couldn’t shake his off-field issues. Suspensions kept him on the sidelines permanently.
11. Art Schlichter
A gambling addiction derailed his NFL journey before it ever found a groove. He was supposed to be the next big thing and ended up more cautionary tale than comeback story.
10. JaMarcus Russell
He fumbled it with poor preparation, but the off-field laziness did him no favors either. When your biggest highlight is holding out for a paycheck, it’s not going to end well.
9. Lawrence Phillips
Phillips had the power and explosiveness to be elite, but he constantly found trouble. Off-field violence and legal problems wiped out any chance at redemption.
8. Antonio Brown
Brown went from Hall of Fame lock to headline machine—and not the good kind. Whether it was outbursts, bizarre stunts, or endless drama, he torched every bridge in sight.
7. Sam Hurd
From role player to drug kingpin? Hurd shocked the league when he was caught trying to distribute large amounts of drugs.
6. Le’Veon Bell
Bell had everything going for him, but contract disputes and distractions led to a decline. He bet on himself, then forgot to cash in with his play.
5. Rae Carruth
Carruth’s story is as dark as it gets in NFL history. His off-field crime was so horrific that it became national news for all the worst reasons.
4. Josh Brent
Brent’s tragic drunk driving accident cost the life of a teammate and forever altered his career. It’s a devastating example of one bad decision changing everything.
3. Dez Bryant
Bryant had moments of greatness, but the sideline antics and maturity concerns caught up with him. Teams are tired of the drama faster than his decline on the field.
Read More: Baker Mayfield Fumbles, Forces Bowles into Roster Panic
2. Maurice Clarett
He was a college legend who flamed out of the NFL before he even got started. Off-field decisions and legal trouble made his pro career basically nonexistent.
Read More: 20 NFL Players Who Were Too Toxic for a Comeback
1. Michael Vick
Vick’s talent was generational, but the dogfighting scandal overshadowed it all. Though he made a comeback, his career—and legacy—never fully recovered from that off-field disaster.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
