Belief is a quarterback’s best friend. You can have all the arm strength and football IQ in the world, but if you don’t believe you’re the best player on the field every Sunday, you’re toast. Some QBs channel that confidence into championships, while others just become legends in their minds. Either way, the NFL has never been short on signal-callers who weren’t exactly lacking in self-assurance.
From fiery leaders to locker room personalities that always had a little extra swagger, these 20 quarterbacks believed they were destined for greatness, whether the rest of the world agreed.
20. Jay Cutler
Cutler had the arm talent to back up his self-confidence, even if his body language sometimes said otherwise. He always believed he could make every throw, for better or worse.
19. Jeff George
George had one of the best arms in NFL history, and he knew it. His confidence sometimes clashed with coaches, but he never lacked for belief in his abilities.
18. Jim McMahon
McMahon’s swagger fit perfectly with the ’85 Bears. He played like every defense was beneath him, and his iconic headbands only added to the persona.
17. Baker Mayfield
From planting flags at midfield to taking slights personally, Mayfield has always thrived on self-belief. He’s never backed down from a challenge, even when the odds weren’t in his favor.
16. Jameis Winston
Winston’s confidence is as infectious as his pregame speeches are memorable. He’s always believed in his cannon arm, even when it got him into turnover trouble.
15. Brett Favre
Favre’s gunslinger mentality made him a legend, but also came from an unshakable belief that he could pull off the impossible. He always played like every throw was destined for a highlight reel.
14. Cam Newton
Newton took the league by storm with his Superman celebrations and MVP swagger. Even as critics piled on, he never lost his belief in his unique style of play.
13. Joe Namath
Broadway Joe famously guaranteed a Super Bowl win before it was cool. Namath didn’t just talk the talk; he strutted into NFL lore.
12. Philip Rivers
Rivers had a mouth as strong as his arm and never hesitated to tell you what he was thinking. His fiery on-field attitude was driven by pure self-belief.
11. Johnny Manziel
Manziel burst onto the scene with the swagger of a rock star, convinced he could make it in the NFL with pure moxie. It didn’t work out, but his confidence was never questioned.
10. Fran Tarkenton
Tarkenton scrambled like the rules of physics didn’t apply to him. His unshakable self-confidence helped redefine the quarterback position.
9. Ben Roethlisberger
Big Ben has always played with the fearlessness of a guy who thinks he’s unbreakable. His confidence in extending plays made him a two-time Super Bowl champion.
8. Michael Vick
Vick redefined the quarterback position, convinced no defender could keep up with his speed and athleticism. That belief made him one of the most electrifying players in NFL history.
7. Aaron Rodgers
Rodgers has never been shy about believing in his arm, football IQ, or place among the all-time greats. His infamous “relax” moment is just one example of his unshakeable confidence.
6. Peyton Manning
Manning always believed he could outsmart every defense in the league. His obsessive preparation and laser focus came from that unrelenting self-belief.
5. Patrick Mahomes
Mahomes plays like he’s in a video game and is convinced no throw is too risky or impossible. His highlight reel backs up that bravado.
4. Tom Brady
Brady might have entered the league with a chip on his shoulder, but he quickly developed a belief that he was destined for greatness. Seven rings later, it’s hard to argue with him.
3. Steve Young
Young had to replace Joe Montana, which required a special kind of confidence. He believed he could be the guy and ensured everyone else did.
2. John Elway
Elway’s cannon arm and fearless playing style made him a legend. He believed he could lead his team back, no matter the deficit.
1. Joe Montana
Cool under pressure and unflinchingly confident, Montana played with the calm assurance of a quarterback who always knew he’d find a way to win. Four Super Bowls later, it’s safe to say he backed it up.
Read More: The 20 Most Overconfident Tennis Stars of All Time
