In a league built on rivalries, trash talk, and deeply divided fan bases, there are still a few rare players who somehow manage to unite the masses. These are the guys who earn respect from every corner of the football world—no matter the jersey they wear or the team they torch on Sundays.
Whether it’s their playing style, leadership, or just being genuinely likable, these NFL stars became universally appreciated in a sport where that’s no small feat. From humble quarterbacks to hard-nosed defenders, here are 25 NFL stars everyone could pretty much agree on.
25. George Kittle
It’s hard not to enjoy someone who plays with that much energy and has that much fun doing it. Kittle brings joy, toughness, and elite talent to every game.
24. Larry Csonka
Even if you weren’t around to watch him bulldoze through defenses, you probably still respect the guy. He was all grit, no flash, and somehow managed to make that cool.
23. Tony Gonzalez
The man could catch everything, block like a lineman, and never made a fuss. Tony G was basically the tight end prototype for a whole generation.
22. Jason Kelce
Offensive linemen rarely become fan favorites, but Kelce made it look easy. Between his Super Bowl parade speech and consistent dominance, he became beloved far beyond Philly.
21. Anquan Boldin
Tough as nails and never backed down from a challenge. Boldin made clutch catches and earned admiration for his fearless playing style.
20. Devin Hester
He only needed a few seconds to make everyone jump out of their seats. Hester made special teams must-watch TV.
19. Fred Taylor
One of the most underrated running backs ever, and fans know it. Taylor ran hard, stayed humble, and always delivered.
18. Terrell Davis
T.D. had a short prime, but what a run it was. You’d be hard-pressed to find anyone with something bad to say about him.
17. Darren Sproles
Small in stature, massive in impact. Every time Sproles touched the ball, it felt like something magical could happen.
16. Luke Kuechly
Kuechly played the game like a professor with pads on. He was smart, instinctive, and left the league with nothing but respect.
15. Hines Ward
Known for his signature smile and devastating blocks, Ward made football fun. He played with passion and always backed it up.
14. Curtis Martin
Martin just quietly went about being one of the most productive backs ever. No drama, no nonsense—just greatness.
13. Chris Long
He brought veteran leadership and personality to every locker room he entered. And off the field, his philanthropy made people root for him even more.
12. Charles Woodson
He did it all—corner, safety, leader, legend. Woodson carried himself like a pro’s pro from start to finish.
11. Russell Wilson
Say what you want about his quirks, but prime Russ was impossible not to respect. He played with heart, poise, and always seemed to pull off something amazing.
10. Reggie Wayne
Wayne was a technician at wide receiver who made it look smooth and effortless. Fans across the league admired how reliable and clutch he was.
9. Joe Thomas
Eleven years of elite play on a not-so-elite team. Thomas gave everything to Cleveland and never once complained.
8. Marshall Faulk
Faulk could do it all—run, catch, block, you name it. He helped redefine what a running back could be in a modern offense.
7. Justin Jefferson
It’s still fairly early, but he’s already made himself impossible to dislike. JJ’s got talent, charisma, and just the right amount of swagger.
6. Steve Smith Sr.
He talked a lot, but always backed it up with big plays and bigger heart. Fans loved his fire, even when he torched their favorite team.
5. Calvin Johnson
Megatron was a superhero in cleats. Dominant on the field, humble off it—just pure class from start to finish.
4. Troy Polamalu
The hair, the hits, the highlight-reel plays—Troy made defense feel electric. He played with a quiet dignity that everyone respected.
3. Barry Sanders
He danced, darted, and spun his way into football lore. Sanders was as gracious as he was great, and nobody ever rooted against him.
Read More: 25 Athletes Who Played Like the Camera Was Always on Them
2. Larry Fitzgerald
Fitzgerald was the human embodiment of sportsmanship. Fans adored him, teammates cherished him, and he aged like fine wine.
Read More: 20 Sports Stars Who Seemed to Have Zero Haters
1. Peyton Manning
Whether you loved his laser passes or his deadpan commercials, Peyton was everyone’s guy. He was both a genius on the field and a personality fans from every city could appreciate.
Read More: 25 Retired NFL Legends We Still Miss Deeply
