Every fan base has that one player they secretly wish wore their team’s jersey. Whether it’s because of the rings, the swagger, or how effortlessly they dominated, these NFL stars made it hard to root against them—unless they were torching your defense.
From generational talents to clutch kings, these guys were the ones who made you sigh, curse, and think, “Man, I wish we had him.” Here are 20 NFL players who sparked jealousy across stadiums every single Sunday.
20. Christian McCaffrey
He’s a highlight reel disguised as a running back and can do everything on the field. Every fan watching their offense struggle to pick up a first down has looked at McCaffrey and felt the sting of envy.
19. DeAndre Hopkins
Even with a rotation of quarterbacks, he still managed to haul in jaw-dropping catches like it was nothing. Fans wished their guy could catch a ball in triple coverage with one hand while making it look casual.
18. Ed Reed
He had this uncanny ability to know exactly where the ball was going before it even left the quarterback’s hand. Watching him play was like watching someone cheat at Madden—but in real life.
17. Rob Gronkowski
The perfect mix of goofy and unstoppable, Gronk racked up touchdowns and partied harder than your favorite rock band. Fans weren’t just jealous of his production—they were envious of how much fun he made football look.
16. Charles Woodson
He could shut you down as a corner, flip the switch, and dominate as a safety. Opposing fans hated seeing him but respected every bit of it.
15. Randy Moss
All it took was one play to ruin your entire afternoon—and Moss did it repeatedly. Fans groaned as he blew past defenders and celebrated like it was personal.
14. Jason Kelce
A center with personality, grit, and Super Bowl rings? Fans wanted that guy anchoring their offensive line and wearing a Mummers’ costume in their championship parade.
13. Marshawn Lynch
He ran madly across the earth and said he had better things to do. Fans couldn’t help but envy how much swagger and authenticity he brought to the game.
12. Aaron Donald
Watching your quarterback get pancaked by Donald was a weekly tradition. Everyone wished they had a wrecking ball like him on their defensive line.
11. Patrick Mahomes
Every time he made a sidearm throw or a no-look pass, opposing fans groaned in unison. It’s hard not to be jealous when a guy is rewriting the quarterback playbook on the fly.
10. Darrelle Revis
They didn’t call it “Revis Island” for nothing—he turned elite receivers into afterthoughts. Fans on the outside looked in and wished their team had someone who could erase half the field like it was nothing.
9. Calvin Johnson
He was built like a defensive end but moved like a ballerina, catching everything in sight. Watching him make impossible catches while your DB flailed in the air was the ultimate pain.
8. Ray Lewis
The energy, the speeches, the intensity—Ray Lewis was a walking documentary. Every fan base wanted a leader like him to fire up their defense.
7. Derrick Henry
He made grown men look like middle schoolers with stiff arms that sent souls into orbit. You couldn’t help but admire his dominance, even while hoping your team somehow didn’t have to tackle him.
6. Joe Burrow
Cool as ice with a cannon for an arm and a wardrobe that screamed confidence. Even if you were rooting against him, you wanted to hang out with him afterward.
5. Tyreek Hill
You blink and he’s already in the end zone doing a backflip. Opposing fans dreaded playing him, but couldn’t deny how fun it would be to cheer for that speed.
4. Aaron Rodgers
Whether it was the Hail Marys or the smug smirks after another ridiculous throw, Rodgers made everything look easy. Fans hated losing to him, and hated how much they wanted a quarterback like him.
3. Troy Polamalu
With his hair flying and instincts dialed to 100, Polamalu made chaos look like an art form. Fans respected his greatness, even if he made life miserable for their team.
Read More: Which NFL Teams Think They’re America’s Team? We Ranked Them
2. Tom Brady
No one liked losing to him, and everyone seemed to do it often. He was the human embodiment of “Why can’t we have nice things?”
Read More: Ranking the 15 NFL Fanbases You Don’t Want to Mess With
1. Barry Sanders
He played for a team that didn’t give him much, but still gave fans magic every Sunday. No matter who you rooted for, some of you always wished Barry was spinning and juking defenders in your team’s colors.
Read More: 15 Most Jealous NFL Stars of All Time
