Fantasy football has completely changed the way we talk about the NFL. Suddenly, it’s not just about wins and losses—it’s about yards, touchdowns, and PPR potential. Players who might’ve flown under the radar back in the day would be household names if they played today, racking up weekly points and dominating league matchups.
This list looks back at some of the most electric, productive, and fantasy-friendly players from past eras who would’ve absolutely thrived in today’s stat-hungry world. From dual-threat backs to volume receivers and touchdown machines, these guys would’ve had your group chat buzzing every Sunday.
20. James Brooks
Brooks was a do-it-all back before that was really a thing, racking up yards as both a runner and a receiver. Fantasy managers today would be drooling over his versatility in a PPR league.
19. Wesley Walker
With blazing speed and a knack for big plays, Walker was a deep-ball specialist. He would’ve been a boom-or-bust WR2 who could single-handedly win you a week.
18. William Andrews
Before injuries cut his career short, Andrews put up monster numbers on the ground and through the air. He’d be a fantasy workhorse with elite RB1 upside.
17. Roy Green
Green was ahead of his time as a receiver who could stretch the field and rack up touchdowns. He’d be a consistent fantasy stud with WR1 potential in modern offenses.
16. Chuck Foreman
Foreman was basically Christian McCaffrey before Christian McCaffrey. He led the league in receptions one year—as a running back—and would be a fantasy cheat code now.
15. Ken Anderson
Anderson put up numbers that were downright futuristic in his era. In today’s pass-heavy league, he’d be a fantasy QB darling with top-10 potential every season.
14. Ottis Anderson
Anderson was a volume monster, regularly carrying the load for his offense. In fantasy terms, he would’ve been the kind of guy who never leaves your starting lineup.
13. Stanley Morgan
Morgan averaged over 19 yards per catch for his career, which is just absurd. He’d be the kind of player who scores 12 points on two catches and leaves you wanting more.
12. Todd Christensen
As a tight end who doubled as a high-volume receiver, Christensen would thrive in today’s fantasy formats. He’d be a weekly TE1 with crazy PPR upside.
11. Roger Craig
Craig was the first player to ever rack up 1,000 yards rushing and receiving in the same season. That kind of dual-threat production would make him a top-three pick in every draft.
10. Steve Grogan
Grogan was a sneaky-good fantasy asset before fantasy football even existed. He could run and throw, and he scored way more touchdowns than most remember.
9. Charlie Joiner
Joiner was one of his generation’s most reliable receivers, which translates beautifully to fantasy. In a modern West Coast offense, he’d rack up catches like crazy.
8. Eric Metcalf
Metcalf was the ultimate flex player—part returner, part receiver, part running back. In today’s fantasy landscape, he’d be the Swiss Army knife that wins you leagues.
7. Harold Jackson
Jackson was consistently productive for over a decade, even when playing in low-volume passing offenses. Imagine what he could do with today’s pass-heavy playbooks.
6. Joe Delaney
Delaney’s career was tragically short, but the flashes he showed were fantasy gold. He would’ve been a breakout RB pick with league-winning potential.
5. Ricky Watters
Watters put up gaudy numbers as both a rusher and receiver, often flying under the radar. He’d be a weekly top-five back who could swing fantasy matchups today.
4. Mark Clayton
As Dan Marino’s favorite target, Clayton was a touchdown machine. In the fantasy era, he’d be a red-zone beast and weekly starter with massive upside.
3. Priest Holmes
Holmes actually played during the early fantasy era but didn’t get the credit he deserved. If he played today, he’d be a fantasy legend with multiple No. 1 finishes.
Read More: 15 NFL Stars Who Always Took the High Road
2. Sterling Sharpe
Sharpe was unstoppable at his peak and would’ve been a perennial WR1 if his career hadn’t ended early. He’d be putting up Davante Adams numbers every single year.
Read More: 10 NFL Quarterbacks From the ’70s Who Could Play Today
1. Marshall Faulk
Faulk is basically the blueprint for the modern fantasy running back. If he were playing now, he’d be the consensus No. 1 overall pick and a weekly fantasy juggernaut.
Read More: 10 Tips to Get Started Playing Fantasy Football
