Being a star in the NFL doesn’t guarantee love from fans, media, or even teammates. Some players just never seemed to shake the narratives that followed them—whether fair, exaggerated, or totally off base.
These 15 NFL superstars put up the stats, won the games, and changed the league, but somehow, the full picture never really made it through. From personality quirks to media spats to flat-out mislabeling, these players deserved a little more grace than they ever got.
15. Cam Newton
Cam Newton was electric on the field and charismatic off it, but his swagger rubbed a lot of people the wrong way. His MVP season should’ve silenced critics, yet people still questioned his leadership and work ethic.
14. Terrell Owens
T.O. was labeled a locker room cancer, but his production was undeniable and his passion often misunderstood. He cried for his quarterback, played through injuries, and got painted as selfish for being brutally honest.
13. Jay Cutler
Jay Cutler’s body language became a meme, but he was tougher than people gave him credit for. Behind the disinterested face was a guy who took a ton of hits and kept getting up.
12. Richard Sherman
Sherman talked a big game, but people forgot he had the play to back it up. His intelligence and articulate nature were often ignored in favor of soundbites and sideline rants.
11. Donovan McNabb
McNabb led the Eagles to consistent success, but Philly never really embraced him. He got more criticism than praise, despite being one of the best quarterbacks of his era.
10. Ricky Williams
Ricky walked away from football in his prime, and people thought he was flakey or soft. In reality, he was prioritizing mental health before that was even a conversation.
9. Randy Moss
Moss was tagged as lazy, but anyone who watched him knew he played the game at a different speed. He wasn’t a diva—he was just that much better than everyone else.
8. Warren Moon
Moon had to go to Canada to prove himself, despite being more than NFL-ready from day one. He was overlooked for far too long because of unfair biases, not a lack of talent.
7. Chad Johnson
Chad was seen as a showboat, but he worked harder than most behind the scenes. His end zone celebrations made headlines, but his love for the game ran deep.
6. Jim McMahon
McMahon was a punk rock quarterback in a league full of company men. His attitude got more attention than his toughness and leadership ever did.
5. Michael Vick
Vick made unforgivable mistakes, but his redemption arc was real. Many people never moved past his past, despite how much he grew and gave back later in life.
4. Tony Romo
Romo was treated like a punchline whenever the Cowboys lost, even if he played lights out. He carried some mediocre rosters and still got all the blame when things went south.
3. Lamar Jackson
Lamar gets doubted every season despite winning an MVP and redefining the quarterback position. Critics harp on his passing, but ignore how much he’s elevated the Ravens with his legs and leadership.
Read more: Ranking the 15 Most Self-Important Golfers of All Time
2. Colin Kaepernick
Kaepernick went from Super Bowl quarterback to league pariah for taking a stand. The conversation around him became so politicized that his football talent got completely lost.
Read more: 10 MLB Franchises That Completely Wasted Their Superstars
1. Barry Sanders
Barry walked away at the peak of his powers, and people questioned his competitive fire. But anyone who watched him knew he gave everything—he was just tired of carrying a franchise that never helped him win.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
