Quarterbacks are supposed to be the calm, collected leaders of the huddle—the ones who keep their cool when everything else is falling apart. But let’s be honest, some of them have a flair for the dramatic and throw tantrums like they’re auditioning for a soap opera.
Whether it was pouting on the sideline, blaming teammates, or throwing a fit when things didn’t go their way, these quarterbacks often acted more like toddlers than team captains. Here are 15 quarterbacks who never quite mastered the art of maturity under pressure.
15. Jay Cutler
Cutler always looked like he’d rather be anywhere else, and his body language screamed “I’m over it” even in the middle of close games. Add in the sideline sulking and visible frustration, and you had the NFL’s reigning king of quarterback apathy.
14. Cam Newton
When things were going well, Cam was all smiles and celebrations. But when the losses piled up, so did the press conference walkouts and postgame pout sessions.
13. Kyler Murray
Kyler’s sideline demeanor has never been accused of being overly supportive. Between visible frustration and rumors about video game habits, he hasn’t exactly exuded veteran poise.
12. Ryan Leaf
Leaf’s legendary meltdowns were part of what derailed his short NFL career. The yelling at reporters and general lack of composure made him a cautionary tale in quarterback behavior.
11. Jeff George
George had all the arm talent in the world, but couldn’t stop clashing with coaches and letting his ego lead the way. He never missed a chance to make things about himself, especially when the going got tough.
10. Baker Mayfield
Baker talks a big game, but the second someone questions him, the chip on his shoulder turns into a full-blown tantrum. Whether it’s calling out the media or brooding after a bad game, subtlety isn’t his strong suit.
9. Aaron Rodgers
Rodgers is as talented as they come, but he’s also a master of the passive-aggressive eye roll. From cryptic interviews to throwing teammates under the bus with a shrug, his drama often outweighs the leadership.
8. Vince Young
Young had a habit of taking criticism personally and letting it affect his attitude. When things didn’t go his way, he’d disappear or let the tension build into full-on sulking.
7. Jay Schroeder
Teammates and coaches alike struggled with Schroeder’s combative nature. He never quite figured out how to be a calming presence, instead opting for finger-pointing and mood swings.
6. Zach Wilson
From deflecting blame in postgame interviews to visibly shutting down on the field, Wilson has had his fair share of babyish moments. His refusal to take accountability didn’t sit well with fans or his teammates.
5. Philip Rivers
Rivers was the king of complaining to referees like a kid fighting bedtime. He never cursed, but his nonstop whining and finger-wagging were legendary.
4. Kerry Collins
Collins could never quite handle the pressure without unraveling a bit. Between locker room outbursts and erratic behavior, his maturity was always in question.
3. Ben Roethlisberger
Big Ben often walked around like the world was against him, especially when injured or criticized. He perfected the “nobody believes in me” act, even when he was the center of attention.
Read More: 15 Quarterbacks Who Could Never Let Anything Go
2. Johnny Manziel
Johnny Football played like the rules didn’t apply to him, on or off the field. When things went sideways, he pouted, partied, or both.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Petulant NFL Quarterbacks of All Time
1. Eli Manning
Eli’s face during games became its own meme-worthy genre. Every time something didn’t go his way, you’d get that classic open-mouthed, “Why me?” expression like someone stole his lunch money.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
