Sometimes, the hype machine gets a little out of control. Whether it’s a first-round pick who never figured it out or a backup who fooled everyone with one hot month, these quarterbacks were more myth than substance.
Fans, media, and teammates tried to sell the idea that these guys were legit. But deep down, we all knew the truth; we don’t want to.
18. Christian Ponder
People acted like he was “sneaky solid,” but the only thing sneaky was how quickly he disappeared. He was a first-round pick who never looked comfortable running an NFL offense.
17. Jimmy Clausen
He had the Notre Dame name and the fake swagger to match. For a while, people thought he was a franchise guy—until they watched him play.
16. Blake Bortles
Everyone rooted for Bortles because he was funny and self-deprecating, but let’s not pretend he was good at quarterbacking. That one AFC Championship run bought him way too much credibility.
15. Drew Lock
He rapped on the sideline, threw the occasional bomb, and somehow people kept calling him “underrated.” In reality, he was just another guy who looked the part and fooled us for a season or two.
14. Matt Cassel
One good year in New England turned into years of starting jobs he never really earned. Teams kept hoping that magic would return, but it never did.
13. Tim Couch
Being the first-ever Browns draft pick back didn’t mean he was good—it just meant he was first. Everyone blamed his struggles on the situation, but he also didn’t exactly elevate anyone around him.
12. Jason Campbell
He had all the measurables and none of the results. Somehow, he bounced around the league for years with people still trying to convince themselves he had untapped potential.
11. Kyle Boller
He once threw a football through the uprights from his knees in a workout, and we all lost our minds. The actual games were much less impressive.
10. Josh Rosen
He was labeled “the most NFL-ready QB” in his class, which in hindsight feels more like a dare than a compliment. The NFL was ready for him to sit on the bench.
9. Kellen Clemens
He was the perpetual backup that coaches loved for some reason. Every preseason, someone would float the idea that maybe he could start—and every regular season proved otherwise.
8. Trevor Siemian
People called him “serviceable,” which is the NFL version of saying “he’s here.” Denver fans tried to talk themselves into him, but the offense never moved.
7. Charlie Whitehurst
“Clipboard Jesus” had elite hair and mediocre everything else. Somehow, his vibes lasted longer than his on-field production ever justified.
6. Colt McCoy
He was always described as “a great locker room guy,” which is a polite way of saying the team hoped he never had to play. But when he did, people acted surprised he wasn’t better.
5. Jake Locker
There was a lot of talk about his toughness and athleticism, but almost none about his accuracy. Everyone wanted him to work out so badly that they ignored the obvious flaws.
4. Brady Quinn
He looked like a quarterback created in a lab, and that’s probably where he should’ve stayed. For some reason, people kept pretending he was one opportunity away from breaking out.
3. Mitchell Trubisky
He had a playoff defense and still couldn’t make it work. Chicago fans spent years defending him when deep down, they knew.
Read More: 15 Highly Paid Quarterbacks Who Never Played Like It
2. Matt Leinart
He had all the USC hype, Heisman buzz, and celebrity cachet—just none of the NFL production. He always seemed more interested in being famous than being great.
Read More: 19 NFL Players Fans Pretended to Love
1. Brock Osweiler
One decent run in Denver turned into a massive contract and a whole lot of disappointment. Everyone kept trying to make Brock happen, and it never came close.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
