The regular season is where reputations are made, but the playoffs? That’s where legends are born. When the lights are brightest and the pressure is sky-high, some NFL players have an uncanny ability to rise to the occasion and deliver when it matters most.
These are the guys who don’t flinch with the season on the line. From icy quarterbacks to relentless defenders, here are the 20 most clutch NFL playoff performers of all time.
20. Adam Vinatieri
When your leg has literally won multiple Super Bowls, you earn a spot on this list. Vinatieri never seemed to miss when it mattered most.
19. Joe Flacco
Say what you want about regular-season Joe, but playoff Joe Flacco was a whole different animal. He went on a legendary tear in 2012 that still stuns people today.
18. Julian Edelman
The guy was a human third-down conversion in the postseason. From crazy catches to MVP moments, Edelman always stepped up when the Pats needed him.
17. Eli Manning
Twice, he took down the Patriots dynasty in the Super Bowl, and both times, he pulled off miracle throws. He may not scream elite, but his playoff résumé is undeniable.
16. Ray Lewis
Ray Lewis brought the fire every time he hit the field, but he somehow turned it up another notch in the playoffs. He was the heartbeat of those Ravens defenses that could shut down anybody.
15. Malcolm Butler
One play can define a legacy, and Butler’s Super Bowl-sealing interception did exactly that. He went from unknown to unforgettable in the blink of an eye.
14. Hines Ward
Tough as nails and always in the right spot, Ward showed up big in huge moments for the Steelers. He could block, catch, and dance in the end zone when it counted.
13. Charles Woodson
Playoff games bring out the intensity, and Woodson thrived on that edge. He was a playmaker every time the stakes got high.
12. Troy Aikman
He never had eye-popping stats, but when the Cowboys needed a steady hand, Aikman always delivered. Three Super Bowl wins say plenty.
11. Marshawn Lynch
Beast Mode wasn’t just a nickname—it was a playoff persona. That legendary run against the Saints alone would earn him a spot, but he kept showing up when the Seahawks needed yards the most.
10. Patrick Mahomes
He’s still in his prime, but Mahomes has already built a playoff legacy. Late-game heroics and comebacks are just part of his routine now.
9. Dwight Clark
Dwight Clark’s most famous moment will always be The Catch, but his postseason career didn’t end there. He continued to deliver big plays on the 49ers’ path to Super Bowl glory.
8. John Riggins
When the Washington offense needed a closer, Riggins answered the call. That Super Bowl run was one of the most dominant stretches by a running back ever.
7. Terrell Davis
T.D. didn’t just show up—he took over. Back-to-back playoff runs with monster yardage and two rings cemented his legacy.
6. Terry Bradshaw
You don’t accidentally win four Super Bowls. Bradshaw saved his best throws for the biggest moments.
5. Aaron Donald
In the biggest game of his life, Donald made the play to seal the Super Bowl. He’s the kind of defender who ends drives and titles.
4. Joe Montana
Cool. Calm. Championship-ready. Montana was so relaxed under pressure, it looked like he was playing a backyard game instead of leading game-winning drives.
3. Jerry Rice
Yes, he already appeared earlier—but let’s be honest, his full playoff résumé deserves the top spot too. Records, rings, and dominance in the biggest games—no one brought it like Rice.
Read More: The 15 Most Clutch NFL Punters of All Time
2. Lawrence Taylor
LT was a one-man wrecking crew who thrived in the postseason. He changed how teams approached offense—even in the biggest games.
Read More: The 17 Most Loathed Opponents in NFL Playoff History
1. Tom Brady
He owns basically every playoff passing record, and his late-game drives are the stuff of legend. If it’s the playoffs, you just assume Brady’s going to win.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
