Quarterbacks are the center of attention by default—but some took that spotlight and made it their personal runway. Whether it was mirror selfies, designer wardrobes, or press conferences that turned into beauty pageants, these guys never met a camera they didn’t love.
From legendary egos to social media selfies, these quarterbacks gave off serious “main character energy.” Here are 15 of the vainest signal-callers to ever grace the gridiron, ranked from extra to most extra.
15. Jimmy Garoppolo
He’s got the jawline of a movie star and the confidence to match. Jimmy G knows he’s handsome—and he’s clearly fine with everyone else knowing it, too.
14. Aaron Rodgers
Rodgers has gone from MVP to mystic guru with a flair for dramatic reveals. Between the slicked-back hair phases and podcast monologues, the vanity vibes are strong.
13. Matt Leinart
Back in his college and early NFL days, Leinart seemed more interested in partying and posing than passing. His Hollywood energy never quite translated to long-term success on the field.
12. Baker Mayfield
Baker’s got a chip on his shoulder and a mirror in his locker. His confidence is sky-high, and he’s never been afraid to hype himself up—even when things weren’t going well.
11. Joe Namath
Broadway Joe was rocking fur coats and pantyhose commercials before it was cool. He was as much about image as he was about innovation on the field.
10. Russell Wilson
Whether he’s rehearsing motivational speeches or posing with Ciara on red carpets, Russ is always camera-ready. The man is constantly in PR mode, even during team huddles.
9. Josh Rosen
Rosen’s confidence outpaced his résumé from day one. He gave off major “I’m smarter than you” vibes and never seemed too shy about it.
8. Jay Cutler
Jay had that permanent look of disinterest, but don’t let it fool you—he cared a lot about being seen as the effortlessly cool guy. His reality TV stint only confirmed that vibe.
7. Tony Romo
Romo loved the spotlight almost as much as he loved extending plays. Whether it was dating pop stars or showing up at high-profile events, Tony was never just the QB—he was the headline.
6. Cam Newton
No one rocks postgame fashion like Cam Newton. The hats, the patterns, the custom everything—it’s a masterclass in football vanity.
5. Johnny Manziel
Manziel was basically a walking Instagram story before that was a thing. He wanted the fame just as much—if not more—than the football.
4. Zach Wilson
Even before stepping on an NFL field, Wilson had the groomed look of a reality dating show contestant. He plays the part of quarterback, but he really looks like he’s auditioning for “The Bachelor.”
Read More: Ranking the Most Charismatic NFL Stars of All Time
3. Tom Brady
Sure, he’s the GOAT—but he’s also a brand. From perfectly tailored suits to TB12 hydration philosophies, Brady’s vanity is as finely tuned as his throwing motion.
Read More: Ranking the 20 Most Extra Players in NFL History
2. Joe Burrow
Burrow walks like a model, dresses like a rockstar, and talks like he already has a Netflix docuseries in the works. He knows he’s cool, and he leans into it at every opportunity.
Read More: Ranking the 15 Most Sensitive MLB Superstars of All Time
1. Jim McMahon
The original rebel QB, McMahon, turned every press appearance into a performance. Between the shades, the swagger, and the absolute refusal to blend in, he was vanity before vanity was cool.
