Some baseball players show up with a vibe check instead of a scouting report. Whether it was the chains, the bat flips, or the walk-up music louder than their stats, these guys brought personality in spades… but maybe not always the responsibility to match.
This list is for the stars who lived for the show but occasionally forgot they were in a game that kept score. From postgame excuses to questionable hustle, they rode the good times hard and disappeared when things got tough.
20. Yasiel Puig
Puig brought fireworks to the field and the dugout, and you never knew what was coming next. When things went wrong, it was usually someone else’s fault—or just not his problem.
19. Manny Ramirez
Manny being Manny was fun until it wasn’t, especially when accountability came knocking. The talent was undeniable, but so were the “who, me?” moments after every controversy.
18. Josh Donaldson
He strutted like he owned the field, but the attitude stayed hot when the bat went cold. Taking responsibility wasn’t always his first instinct—blame usually landed elsewhere.
17. Carlos Gómez
Every game was a party for Gómez, complete with bat flips and chest pounding. But when he struck out or missed the cutoff man, he somehow acted like the vibes were still immaculate.
16. Aroldis Chapman
Chapman brought heat on the mound and ice in the accountability department. He often acted like blown saves were technicalities and off-field issues were best left unmentioned.
15. Yoenis Céspedes
The man rode horses to spring training but ghosted the Mets mid-season. Flair for the dramatic? Yes. Ownership of consequences? Not really.
14. Jonathan Papelbon
He stared down opponents like a villain, but his finger always pointed outward when things unraveled. He brought energy, but rarely introspection.
13. Javy Báez
Electric when locked in, erratic when he wasn’t, and not always willing to admit which version was on the field. Javy thrived on highlight plays but ducked accountability when fundamentals failed him.
12. Hanley Ramírez
He looked like a superstar, acted like a superstar, and occasionally played like one—but wasn’t too interested in answering for the off days. The swagger stayed, even when the results dipped.
11. Trevor Bauer
Bauer talked like a genius and tweeted like a rebel, but rarely accepted fault when things went sideways. He brought chaos to the clubhouse and seldom owned the aftermath.
10. Matt Kemp
He had MVP-level charisma and All-Star-level expectations, but often disappeared in big moments. When he underperformed, excuses usually came faster than adjustments.
9. Bryce Harper (early career)
Young Bryce had all the hype and twice the swagger, but not always the maturity to match. If things didn’t go his way, someone else was getting blamed—probably loudly.
8. José Reyes
He danced, smiled, and sprinted when things were going well. But when criticism showed up, he often ducked and weaved around it like a bad baserunning decision.
7. David Wells
Wells loved the nightlife almost as much as the spotlight and wasn’t shy about it. He pitched on his terms—and if something went wrong, don’t expect a heartfelt apology.
6. Elvis Andrus
He played like he was in a music video and carried himself like a franchise star. But when it came time to step up as a leader, the silence was louder than the chain clanking on his chest.
5. Alex Rodriguez (pre-Yankees redemption arc)
He was all glitz and record-breaking contracts, but early A-Rod wasn’t keen on taking the blame, especially when things got messy. The vibe was superstar; the accountability was MIA.
4. Johnny Cueto
Cueto’s shimmy and style made him a must-watch, but we rarely looked inward. When he struggled, the flair stayed high even as ERA did the same.
3. Nick Swisher
He brought frat-party energy to the dugout daily, but not always the discipline to go with it. When his production dipped, it was still high-fives and smiles—just no answers.
Read More: 15 Most Intimidating MLB Players of All Time
2. Robinson Canó
Effortless talent met laid-back attitude; sometimes that combo meant disappearing in big spots. He rarely seemed pressed to explain whether it was performance issues or suspensions.
Read More: 15 Baseball Divas Who Were Always the Center of Attention
1. Manny Machado (early career)
Machado played with flash and confidence, but responsibility wasn’t on his list early on. From loafing on grounders to dustups with opponents, he looked the part of a superstar without always acting like one.
