College football is all about swagger, but some programs might want to take a quick look in the mirror. Whether it’s past glories, inflated fan expectations, or a social media following that’s doing too much, these teams carry themselves like royalty—even when the results say otherwise.
We’re not saying they don’t have tradition, passion, or moments of brilliance. We’re just saying maybe, just maybe, they think they belong in the penthouse when they’re really chilling in the lobby bar. Here are 30 college football programs that think they’re bigger than they actually are.
30. BYU
BYU fans will tell you they’re a powerhouse, but they’ve been living off that 1984 title for a long time. Maybe next year things we’ll be different.
29. Arkansas
The SEC swagger is strong, but Arkansas hasn’t sniffed real relevance in decades. Every decent start to a season ends in heartbreak and delusion.
28. Arizona State
ASU acts like it’s one coach away from greatness every single year. The talent flashes are real, but the consistency sure isn’t.
27. Illinois
They had some nice years with Juice Williams and a Rose Bowl run, but that was ages ago. Every time they string together two wins, the hype machine starts cranking.
26. Kansas
Basketball school through and through, but one good football season had them talking like a sleeping giant. Calm down, Jayhawks—it was one season, not a dynasty.
25. Texas Tech
They love to brag about the air raid days, but not much has happened since. Outside of Patrick Mahomes highlights, the trophy case is pretty quiet.
24. South Carolina
Gamecock fans bring the energy like they’re perennial contenders. Unfortunately, the win column rarely matches the confidence.
23. Cal
They think being in the Bay Area gives them prestige, but their football product hasn’t backed that up in years. Marshawn Lynch highlights can only carry you so far.
22. NC State
Wolfpack fans always believe this is their year, but the ceiling seems stuck at “almost relevant.” They live in the shadow of both Clemson and UNC—and still talk big.
21. Purdue
Purdue churns out quarterbacks but not many playoff runs. They’ll beat a ranked team now and then, then immediately start puffing their chest.
20. Virginia Tech
The “Enter Sandman” entrance is iconic, but the program hasn’t kept that same energy lately. The swagger still screams early-2000s greatness even if the record doesn’t.
19. Missouri
They came into the SEC like they owned the place, but it’s been a mixed bag ever since. Mizzou talks a big game, but the big wins are pretty rare.
18. Louisville
Lamar Jackson made everyone forget this team usually lives in the middle of the pack. They ride that one Heisman like it was a national title.
17. Iowa State
Every time they win eight games, they get labeled a “dark horse.” It’s a fun story, but not quite the powerhouse they sometimes act like.
16. Maryland
They’ve got the flashy uniforms and a Big Ten home, but the results haven’t exactly screamed elite. It’s all sizzle, very little steak.
15. UCLA
UCLA has that LA shine and blue-blood energy, but it rarely shows up on the field. The brand is big, the results… not so much.
14. Michigan State
MSU had a strong run under Mark Dantonio, but lately they’ve been chasing ghosts. The Spartans still talk like they’re in the Big Ten elite circle.
13. TCU
Yes, they made the playoff title game—but got absolutely steamrolled once there. Great season, but let’s not act like it’s an annual occurrence.
12. Nebraska
Every offseason is “we’re back” season in Lincoln. It’s been a long time since that actually rang true on the scoreboard.
11. Florida State
They’ve had some real glory, but their down years have been brutal—and somehow, they still walk with national title-level confidence. The Seminole faithful believe no rebuild should ever apply to them.
10. Baylor
Baylor acts like a new power, but the scandal era and inconsistency make that hard to buy. They’re not quite ready to sit at the adults’ table just yet.
9. Miami
The swagger is legendary, but these days it’s mostly historical fiction. “The U” hasn’t been truly “back” since flip phones were a thing.
8. Auburn
Every win over Alabama buys Auburn five years of irrational confidence. The coaching turnover and chaos say otherwise.
7. Tennessee
The Vols have that SEC pride and a stadium that shakes, but their expectations rarely match the results. A solid season can spiral into championship delusion real quick.
6. Oklahoma State
They’ve been good, sometimes very good, but not that good. The way they talk about Bedlam makes you forget the win-loss record in that rivalry.
5. USC
Hollywood, tradition, and Heismans—sure, it’s glamorous. But they’ve been trying to reboot the glory days for over a decade.
4. Penn State
Penn State fans always think they should be in the playoff mix, but they just can’t get over the hump. The brand is huge, but the postseason resume isn’t.
3. Notre Dame
National following? Absolutely. National championship in the modern era? Still waiting.
Read More: The 15 Most Smug College Football Programs
2. Texas
The “Texas is back” jokes write themselves. No fanbase rides vibes harder than this one, no matter how many 7–5 seasons roll through.
Read More: Ranking the 10 Most Bitter College Football Coaching Exits
1. Texas A&M
No one does more with less actual success than the Aggies. The facilities are flashy, the fans are loud, and the expectations are through the roof—but the results just haven’t shown up.
Read More: 20 College Football Coaches Who Overstayed Their Welcome
