In baseball, the worst place to be isn’t rock bottom—it’s baseball purgatory. You’re not bad enough to justify a full rebuild, but you’re also not good enough to seriously compete for a World Series. You exist in that awkward space where you can’t quite tear it down, but you also can’t take the next step.
Some teams spend decades in this frustrating middle ground, keeping their fans hopeful just long enough to break their hearts. Let’s count down the 10 MLB franchises that are currently stuck in baseball limbo.
10. San Francisco Giants – Not Bad, Not Great, Just There
Remember when the Giants were baseball’s odd-year dynasty? Those days feel long gone. Since their 107-win season in 2021, San Francisco has been in mid-tier limbo, always hovering around .500 but never doing anything meaningful in October. Their free agency strategy is basically “almost sign a superstar,” and their farm system isn’t strong enough to push them over the top.
9. Boston Red Sox – What’s the Plan Here?
The Red Sox are too talented to tear it all down, but too inconsistent to be real contenders. One year they’re a playoff team, the next they’re in last place. The front office keeps operating like a small-market team despite their massive budget, and fans are tired of watching stars walk away (hello, Mookie Betts). Are they rebuilding? Competing? Even they don’t seem to know.
8. Minnesota Twins – Playoff Punching Bags
The Twins are a regular-season machine, but once October hits? They might as well go home early. They finally broke their infinite playoff losing streak in 2023, but this team never feels like a real World Series threat. They’ll win the AL Central some years, get bounced immediately, then run it back the exact same way. Rinse. Repeat.
7. Texas Rangers – (Unless 2023 Was a Fluke)
Wait, the Rangers just won the World Series! How are they here? Well, they spent a ton of money to get that ring, and if they don’t keep spending, they risk sliding back into baseball purgatory. They’re one bad season away from being a bloated, expensive team that’s stuck in the middle. If they keep building, they can escape. If not… welcome to the list.
6. Chicago Cubs – Half-In, Half-Out Forever
The Cubs keep making moves just good enough to keep fans interested but never aggressive enough to return to World Series contention. Their 2016 championship should have been the start of a dynasty, but instead, they dismantled everything. Now, they’re in that awkward space where they have decent talent but not enough to be a serious contender.
5. Los Angeles Angels – Wasting Generational Talent Since 2012
Mike Trout. Shohei Ohtani. And… nothing to show for it. The Angels have mastered the art of being just competitive enough to not rebuild but never actually winning anything. With Ohtani gone, they might finally embrace a rebuild, but history says they’ll just sign the wrong free agents and keep cycling through mediocrity.
4. Milwaukee Brewers – Forever Stuck at “Pretty Good”
The Brewers are always a decent team, but never quite great. Their pitching is elite, but their offense is never scary enough to make them a real contender. Every October, they seem to get exposed by teams with actual firepower. And with an ownership group that refuses to spend big, they’re stuck in a cycle of good but not good enough.
3. St. Louis Cardinals – The “We’re Never Bad” Curse
The Cardinals are never truly awful, but they’ve also struggled to be a real force in the playoffs for years. Their unwillingness to fully embrace a rebuild keeps them in this weird space where they win enough games to stay respectable but don’t have the firepower to make deep postseason runs. They need to pick a lane—compete for real or tear it down.
Read More: 10 Iconic Video Game Franchises That Defined the Industry
2. Seattle Mariners – The Team That’s Always One Step Away
The Mariners finally made the playoffs in 2022, but instead of building on that, they went right back to hovering around mediocrity. Their pitching is strong, but their offense is painfully inconsistent, and they refuse to spend like a real contender. Every season, they look like they’re on the verge of something big—until they disappoint.
Read More: Ranking Every NFL Team From Worst to Best: 24-25 Season
1. New York Mets – The Definition of Chaos
No team embodies baseball purgatory more than the Mets. They go all-in, then tear it down, then go all-in again, then sell again. Their farm system is solid, but their front office operates with zero patience, constantly flipping between competing and rebuilding. Despite their massive payroll, they’re never a true World Series contender. The Mets are trapped in a never-ending cycle of dysfunction.
Read More: Ranking the 20 Most Delusional MLB Fan Bases
