Football is a game of talent, toughness, and being able to deliver when the stakes are high. Some players rise to the occasion, while others… not so much. Whether it was a huge contract, a big playoff moment, or just the pressure of playing in a major market, these guys cracked under the weight of expectations.
Here’s our countdown of 15 NFL players who just couldn’t handle the heat.
15. Ryan Leaf – The Gold Standard of Busts
It’s impossible to make a list like this without starting with Ryan Leaf. Drafted right after Peyton Manning in 1998, Leaf was supposed to be the Chargers’ franchise QB. Instead, he was a turnover machine with a bad attitude who flamed out of the league faster than a soggy match.
14. David Carr – The Sack Magnet
Carr was the first-ever draft pick for the Houston Texans, and let’s just say it didn’t go well. He got sacked 76 times in his rookie year and never recovered. Maybe he could’ve been great in a different situation, but the pressure of being a No. 1 pick on an expansion team crushed him.
13. Johnny Manziel – Too Much Party, Not Enough Football
“Johnny Football” was a college legend, but once he got to the NFL, his priorities were more Vegas and less playbook. The Browns took a chance on him, but he never put in the work, and the pressure of being a first-round QB in Cleveland (yikes) sent him packing fast.
12. Mitchell Trubisky – The One Taken Before Mahomes
Trubisky was already facing pressure as a No. 2 overall pick, but the fact that the Bears passed on Patrick Mahomes and Deshaun Watson for him? That made it brutal. Trubisky had moments, but when it came time to win big games, he just wasn’t the guy.
11. Matt Leinart – College Legend, NFL Flop
Leinart dominated at USC, winning a Heisman and a national championship. But in the NFL? He was more famous for holding a clipboard than throwing touchdowns. The pressure of leading a team seemed too much, and he quickly faded into backup QB purgatory.
10. Blair Walsh – The Infamous Miss
Kickers have one job—make kicks when they count. Walsh was fine in the regular season, but his career-defining moment came in the 2015 playoffs when he shanked a 27-yard field goal against the Seahawks. Vikings fans are still recovering from that one.
9. JaMarcus Russell – Million-Dollar Arm, One-Dollar Work Ethic
Russell was the definition of a draft bust. The Raiders gave him a $61 million contract, and he repaid them by showing up out of shape and barely trying. He once got caught submitting blank film study tapes. The moment was too big for him, and so were his weekly post-game meals.
8. Nick Anderson – The Buffalo Curse
Bills fans have been through a lot, and Anderson didn’t help. He was part of the defense that gave up a 32-point lead to the Oilers in the biggest collapse in playoff history. When things got tough, his game disappeared faster than the Bills’ Super Bowl hopes in the ‘90s.
7. Mark Sanchez – The Butt Fumble Forever
Sanchez actually won some playoff games, but when you become a meme for one of the most embarrassing plays in NFL history, you make the list. The “Butt Fumble” will live forever, and that’s exactly why Sanchez lands here.
6. Carson Wentz – From MVP-Caliber to Afterthought
Wentz looked like the future of the NFL in 2017 before an injury sidelined him and Nick Foles led the Eagles to a Super Bowl. After that, he just couldn’t handle the pressure. Philly moved on, Indy gave him a shot, Washington gave him a shot—none of it worked.
5. Tony Romo – Mr. Playoff Disaster
Romo had all the talent, but when the playoffs rolled around, he found a way to collapse. Whether it was the infamous bobbled snap against Seattle or his knack for late-game interceptions, the pressure of the big moment always got the best of him.
4. Jay Cutler – Too Cool for the Moment
Cutler had the arm talent, but he never looked like he cared. The guy had an “whatever” attitude in the biggest moments, and Bears fans will never forget him watching from the sideline during the NFC Championship while his team fell apart.
3. Josh Rosen – The “Chosen One” Who Wasn’t
Rosen talked a big game before the draft, claiming the teams that passed on him would regret it. Spoiler: they didn’t. The pressure of being a franchise QB clearly wasn’t for him, and he bounced around to multiple teams before disappearing from the league.
Read More: Ranking The 2024 NFC NFL Coaches From Worst to Best
2. Cam Newton – Big Talk, No Finish
Newton was electric at his peak, but the Super Bowl 50 meltdown was brutal. Not diving for the fumble? Walking out of the post-game interview? The moment was too big, and he never recovered his MVP form.
Read More: Ranking Every NFL Team From Worst to Best: 24-25 Season
1. Kirk Cousins – “You Like That?” (Until the Playoffs Start)
Cousins puts up great stats… in September through November. But when the pressure is on? Let’s just say he’s not exactly Mr. Clutch. Whether it’s prime-time games or the playoffs, Cousins turns into a different quarterback when the stakes are high.
Read More: The 15 Most Disappointing Quarterbacks of the 2024-25 NFL Season
