The NFL is a league of second chances, but not everyone bounces back the same way. For some players, a scandal—whether legal trouble, locker room drama, or off-field controversy—completely changed the course of their careers.
These 14 stars were once on top of the football world, but after their scandals hit the headlines, things were never quite the same. Some lost the trust of fans, others lost their starting jobs, and a few never returned to the league at all.
14. Ray Rice
He was once one of the league’s most productive running backs and a Super Bowl champion. But after a video surfaced of him in a violent domestic incident, his NFL career ended overnight.
13. Antonio Brown
Few players were more electrifying than AB in his prime. But after a series of bizarre incidents and off-field scandals, teams stopped answering his calls.
12. Michael Vick
Vick was the ultimate dual-threat quarterback until his dogfighting scandal landed him in prison. He returned to the league, but the shadow of his past never really left.
11. Josh Gordon
Gordon’s talent was undeniable, but repeated violations of the league’s substance abuse policy kept derailing his career. Every comeback felt like the last shot, and eventually, the opportunities dried up.
10. Deshaun Watson
Once seen as a future face of the league, Watson’s legal troubles completely altered his public image. Even after returning to the field, things have felt different.
9. Plaxico Burress
Burress was a hero for the Giants in their Super Bowl run, but a self-inflicted gunshot wound—and the legal mess that followed—derailed his momentum. He made a brief comeback, but never recaptured his old form.
8. Randy Gregory
He had sky-high potential but couldn’t stay out of trouble with the league’s policies. Teams kept giving him chances, but his inconsistency became the headline.
7. Johnny Manziel
Johnny Football was must-see TV in college and brought massive hype into the NFL. But the off-field chaos quickly outweighed his on-field production.
6. Aldon Smith
Smith looked like a future Hall of Famer early in his career. Then came the arrests, suspensions, and a long fall from grace.
5. Kareem Hunt
After video evidence of a violent altercation came out, the Chiefs quickly moved on. He found another team, but the scandal has always hung over his name.
4. Martavis Bryant
Bryant was a game-breaking receiver when he was on the field. Unfortunately, multiple suspensions and substance issues sidelined what could’ve been a dominant career.
Read More: The 10 Most Controversial College Basketball Player Suspensions of All Time
3. Richie Incognito
He was already known as a tough guy, but the bullying scandal with a teammate took things to another level. Though he eventually returned, his reputation never fully recovered.
Read More: Ranking the 25 Most Scandalous MLB Stars Ever
2. Greg Hardy
Hardy was a dominant pass rusher, but after a disturbing domestic violence case, his NFL future evaporated. He tried other ventures, but the league had clearly moved on.
Read More: 21 Sports Icons Who Ruined Their Reputation Overnight
1. Aaron Hernandez
Hernandez had the talent to be one of the best tight ends in the league. His shocking arrest and eventual conviction stunned the sports world and brought his football career to a tragic and abrupt end.
Stay in the Game With the Latest Scores, Highlights, and Stories — Follow GamerKoala on MSN.
