Winning a Super Bowl cements a quarterback’s place in history—but not every champion was a household name or an all-time great. Some QBs found themselves hoisting the Lombardi Trophy thanks to elite defenses, dominant running games, or simply being in the right place at the right time, despite otherwise unremarkable or inconsistent careers.
Whether they were journeymen, backups thrust into the spotlight, or starters who never quite reached elite status, these quarterbacks defied expectations to claim football’s ultimate prize. Here are ten Super Bowl-winning QBs whose careers didn’t quite live up to the glory of their championship moment.
10. Eli Manning
Eli Manning’s two Super Bowl wins overshadow his mediocre regular-season performance. With a .500 career win-loss record and leading the league in interceptions in 2013, Manning’s success was largely due to exceptional defensive play and fortunate circumstances rather than his own elite skills.
9. Mark Rypien
Mark Rypien’s Super Bowl XXVI MVP performance belies a short career peak and overall mediocre career. With only two Pro Bowl appearances and inconsistent play, Rypien’s success may have been largely due to Washington’s stellar offensive line and running game.
8. Jim Plunkett
Jim Plunkett’s career was a rollercoaster, marked by struggles and comebacks. Despite winning two Super Bowls with the Raiders, his overall NFL performance was inconsistent. While his overall statistics were not elite, his ability to lead teams to Super Bowl victories demonstrates significant skill and leadership.
7. Joe Flacco
Joe Flacco’s 2013 Super Bowl win with the Ravens was more luck than skill. His playoff run included the “Mile High Miracle” – a 70-yard touchdown pass that many called a fluke. In the Super Bowl, he benefited from a power outage that seemed to halt the 49ers’ momentum.
6. Nick Foles
Nick Foles led the Eagles to their first Super Bowl victory in 2018, but his career has been inconsistent. After brief stints with several teams, Foles retired in 2024.
5. Doug Williams
Doug Williams led Washington to a Super Bowl XXII victory, but his overall career stats were fairly mediocre. With a 38-42-1 record as a starter and only 16,998 passing yards over 9 seasons, Williams’ singular exceptional performance doesn’t outweigh his inconsistent career.
4. Jim McMahon
Jim McMahon, known for his rebellious attitude, won two Super Bowl rings despite fairly mediocre career stats. His 1985 Bears victory was marred by controversy, including a false story that sparked death threats. McMahon’s second ring came as a backup for the Packers, where he barely contributed on the field.
3. Jeff Hostetler
Jeff Hostetler led the Giants to a Super Bowl XXV victory in 1991, despite being a career backup. He took over for an injured Phil Simms late in the season and managed the offense effectively. Overall, compared to elite quarterbacks, Hostetler left something to be desired.
Related: These 15 Legendary NFL Coaches Dominated the Gridiron
2. Brad Johnson
Brad Johnson’s Super Bowl victory with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2003 is tainted by controversy. He admitted to paying $7,500 to have game balls scuffed up before Super Bowl XXXVII, violating NFL rules.
Related: 15 NFL Running Backs Who Changed the Game Forever
1. Trent Dilfer
Trent Dilfer’s Super Bowl XXXV performance was underwhelming, completing just 12 of 25 passes for 153 yards and one touchdown. The Ravens’ dominant defense was most likely what carried the team to victory. Dilfer’s regular season stats were modest (1,502 yards, 12 TDs, 11 INTs in 11 games), but he led the team to a 7-1 record in his starts.
