In baseball, even bad teams can get lucky once in a while. But some franchises have spent the last decade as background noise, mostly forgotten once Opening Day buzz wears off. Whether it’s lack of postseason appearances, front office confusion, or just pure irrelevance, these 15 teams have faded hard from the spotlight.
Here are the MLB franchises that haven’t truly mattered in over a decade — ranked from forgettably irrelevant to historically invisible.
15. Milwaukee Brewers
They make the playoffs here and there but always leave quietly. It’s like they RSVP to October, show up for one drink, and bounce.
14. Toronto Blue Jays
They’ve had talent, hype, and bat flips — but not a deep playoff run to show for it. Every year feels like it should be their year, and yet, here we are.
13. Texas Rangers
Yes, they just won a World Series — but let’s be honest, the ten years before that were a tumbleweed-filled wasteland. Credit for waking up recently, but the long nap before that counts.
12. Cincinnati Reds
They’re always rebuilding and somehow always rebuilding from a rebuild. The young talent is exciting, but we’ve seen this movie before — and it never gets to the good part.
11. Detroit Tigers
The 2010s Verlander-Cabrera squads were fun, and then… silence. They’ve been stuck in a decade-long fog of bad contracts and worse drafts.
10. San Diego Padres
They’re always offseason winners and regular season enigmas. The roster says “World Series,” but the results say “fourth place.”
9. Colorado Rockies
They have the most beautiful stadium in baseball and the most baffling front office. Every time you think they might try to compete, they extend a 38-year-old reliever instead.
8. Pittsburgh Pirates
They had a little Wild Card spark in the early 2010s, and then vanished like a ghost. Ownership seems more interested in bobblehead nights than baseball.
7. Miami Marlins
They’ll sneak into the playoffs once a decade just to remind you they exist. Otherwise, it’s been years of empty seats and fire sales.
6. Kansas City Royals
They had a magical two-year run in 2014–15 and immediately went back to the baseball witness protection program. Though they had a nice playoff run in 2024, that World Series glow faded fast.
5. Los Angeles Angels
Two of the greatest players of this generation — and absolutely nothing to show for it. It’s almost impressive how little they’ve done with so much talent.
4. Oakland Athletics
They traded everyone, gutted the roster, and might leave the city — yet somehow still claim to be “strategic.” A’s fans deserve therapy and a new team, in that order.
3. Chicago White Sox
Occasional preseason hype, followed by five months of frustration and a September collapse. It’s like clockwork, but with more dugout arguments.
Read More: The 15 Biggest Playoff Chokers in MLB History
2. Washington Nationals
That 2019 World Series feels like it happened in a dream. Since then, it’s been nothing but losses, trades, and sad vibes.
Read More: 10 MLB Franchises That Are Stuck in Baseball Purgatory
1. Baltimore Orioles
Yes, they just got good — now. But the previous decade was a black hole of blown rebuilds, last-place finishes, and absolutely zero relevance.
Read More: 10 MLB Franchises Baseball Fans Need to See Play in Person
